Worn where it was walked

A ranking left as a by-product can be farmed — unless the trace and the act are the same thing

PageRank, R815’s subject, was a ranking nobody meant to make, recovered from traces that authors left while doing their own work. Its weakness was stated on the page: a by-product ranking can be farmed by manufacturing the traces without the judgement — links made to look like votes. The farm works because a link is cheap and divorceable from what it pretends to vote for. A link can be laid down by someone who never went there.

Not every by-product trace comes apart that way. Where feet wear grass, the trace and the act are one material fact: to leave the mark is to do the thing. A desire path — also called a desire line, social trail, cow path, donkey path, elephant path — is the unplanned trail formed where erosion from foot traffic records that people chose to walk there. Planners have a standing relationship with them. On campuses the standard sequence repeats: the official walk takes the long way around, students cut the corner, the grass dies, grounds crews reseed it, and the grass dies again. Ohio State’s Oval, Futility Closet notes, got its present pattern of paved walks that way: as buildings went up in the early twentieth century, students wore paths in the grass to the popular destinations, and those paths informed the paving that followed. Urban planners sometimes read new-fallen snow the same way, to see where feet want to go before they decide where feet should.

Hold the cost of a fake mark next to the link’s. To fake a link’s vote you build a page nobody asked for and point it somewhere; the whole of the work is making the counterfeit. To fake a desire path’s vote you must walk the route hundreds of times — through whatever weather, at whatever hour — and every one of those walks is a genuine traversal of the route, by a person who went from the origin to the destination. The planner who paves the worn line is not reading an opinion poll about where people would like to go. She is reading a ledger of where they went. The trace is inseparable from the cost because the trace is the cost, spent in public.

The separation fails even when the institution fights it. A 2020 study of a closed desire path in a Sydney park found usage dropped when it was shut, then recovered to four times its original level; the researchers called the behaviour persistent disobedience, and forty percent of pedestrians surveyed said they simply preferred the shortcut. At Tufts, a fence was extended across the worn route up a hill and the grass reseeded — and the curved footpath reappeared anyway, following the same desire. You cannot fake wear into the ground. You can only do it.

The honest narrowing is the erosion side, and it is stated: desire paths are not free for the land. Worn networks damage vegetation, erode hillsides, and can disrupt wildlife, which is why park officials put up logs and signs — and why, in fragile country, the inseparable-trace property is a problem, not a virtue. And the paving does not always follow the walking: institutions sometimes simply re-seed and fence forever. But where the reading is allowed — wait for the grass to speak, then pave what it said — the resulting map has a property no manufactured-vote map has. A fake link is a vote cast without the journey. A fake desire path would be a journey taken without a destination — and there is no quicker way to make that journey than to take it, which is the thing the ledger records.

The quad, from above. A schematic toy, stated plainly. Eleven-by-eleven grid: the dorm is at the left edge, the library at the right edge, the gym at the far corner. Three kinds of ground: pavement costs 1 per step, grass costs 2 (rougher walking) but each traversal wears it, worn-brown ground paves itself at a wear of 10. Walkers always take the least-effort route through the current ground. Each press sends fifty walkers. Then try to fake it: press “plant one fake trail”, which sends a single walker down a useless corner route — count what it takes to get it paved.

PageRank’s ranking survived while making a link cost more than the ranking it bought. Where feet make the marks, the counterfeit budget is paid in the only currency the ledger accepts: the walks themselves. There is no cheaper way to leave the mark. That is the whole of the defence, and it needs no enforcement — the ground keeps the books, and it does not take cheques.