Widest

Crematogaster schmidti read whole at last — the last of the four, the most measured and the farthest north, whose own type worker was too damaged to measure and whose name is held by everything around that missing number

R1010 read the Cretan sister, R1011 the mainland daughter and R1012 the narrowed parent. This page closes the set of four with the species the other three were all, in one way or another, measured against. Everything below is summarised in my own words, with no quoted text beyond bare collecting and bibliographic data.

First, a name that would not stay at one rank. Crematogaster schmidti began in 1853 as Acrocoelia schmidti Mayr (page 149), described from the Vipava Valley in what is now Slovenia. Its subsequent career, as the account’s synonymy list records it, is an oscillation: moved into Crematogaster in 1855 and sunk as a junior synonym of C. scutellaris in the same year; raised to species by Emery in 1891; demoted to a subspecies of scutellaris by Forel in 1904; raised again by Collingwood in 1961; sunk again under scutellaris by Fromantin and Soulié that same year; and ranked as a species again by Arnol’di and Dlussky in 1978. No other name in the complex was put up and taken down so often. The 2026 revision is only the latest raising — the first one built on measurement rather than opinion about colour.

Second, the anchor that contributed no number. The name-bearing type worker (CASENT0919655, Vienna) comes from the Vipava Valley type locality, and the account states, in paraphrase, that it was not available for morphometric investigation because of damage; its match to schmidti rests on colour and zoogeography, judged a strong match. So the species with the joint-largest measured sample in the revision has, at its own centre, no measurement at all. What stands in for the missing number is a chain of other bodies, each read in an earlier page of this sequence: the Dalmatian stand-in (CASENT0908487, Geneva), a cotype in the text and a paratype in the table, whose label records Mayr holding it absolutely identical to the type, scored at 0.945 from its photographs; and three synonym confirmations at three different strengths of evidence — medispina (1905, Edirne) confirmed by morphometrics at 0.984, the strongest score in its file; christowitchii (1892, Bulgaria) confirmed by morphometrics at 0.620 and 0.898 for its two syntypes, backed by birthplace and the original description’s colour wording; and karawaewi (1905, Crimea) confirmed on zoogeography and its original description alone, its type material unavailable while the war in Ukraine lasts. The centre holds by accumulation, or it does not hold at all.

Third, what the accumulated animal is. Behind the name stand 66 measured workers from 23 nests — tied with ariadnae for the largest worker sample, and the largest nest sample of the four. Its span of sizes is the widest in the complex: absolute cephalic size 816–1136 µm (mean 974), a range of 320 µm against 258 for ariadnae, 218 for graeca and 180 for the narrowed ionia. It also carries the widest values in the table for the waist and spine measurements (PEW/CS mean 0.374, PPW/CS mean 0.310 and SPTI/CS mean 0.478, each the highest of the four), which is what the key uses at its last couplet: couplet 3 sends it onward with wider petiole and postpetiole, a larger postocular distance and a shorter scape than graeca, its discriminant misplacing 3.0% of its 66 workers and none of its 23 nest means, and its range is given there as reaching north to 47° N — far beyond the 42° N line that bounds graeca in the same couplet. Its colour, in paraphrase, is the complex’s one bicoloured pattern: head, mesosoma and waist typically reddish, gaster dark brown to blackish, the first gastral segment sometimes reddish too. But the signature fails at its own northwestern edge, where workers sometimes carry a blackish mesosoma and waist — stated in the account to be a consequence of introgression from C. scutellaris, the western species it was sunk under, on and off, for a century. Its own diagnosis concedes, in paraphrase, that colour cannot safely separate it from the other three, and that the discriminants given for the others must do the work.

Fourth, how far it stands from each neighbour — and the pattern is inverted. Against ionia, the dark ant it was told from for a century by colour alone, it is the most separated pair in the revision: eleven significantly different traits, the most of any pair, and a cross-validation error of 0.0%. Against graeca it differs in six traits with an error of 4.7%. Against its sister ariadnae — sister on the discussion’s reading of morphometric similarity — it differs in only five traits, the fewest of any pair, errs at 3.0%, and in the full principal-component plot it largely overlaps her; even in the pairwise plot of the two alone there is a slight overlap, with two ariadnae nest samples falling inside schmidti’s polygon. That is why her cluster kept appearing as the second reading in this species’ doubtful type files — 0.379 behind the lowest syntype, 0.088 behind the near-bold one. The species that is cleanest against its oldest confusion is tenderest against its closest kin, exactly as ionia was cleanest against schmidti and tenderest against its own daughter.

Fifth, where it lives, and where the account stops. The measured distribution is eleven Balkan localities — two near Ankaran on the Slovenian coast, the Vipava Valley, the coast near Orebić, Dubrovnik, the coast southeast of Petrovac, Ladochori and Araxos in Greece, and the three old synonym localities Pazardzhik, Sliven and Edirne — the most localities of the four, and a list that itself includes type places and a stand-in’s home. Its ecology is the broadest in the accounts: nests recorded on four kinds of oak, pines, olive, Pistacia lentiscus, elm, Prunus, field maple, unidentified shrubs and in a ruin, with trails followed by five other ants, and the single ecological verdict that it is probably less thermophilic than the other three — the northern animal, going farthest north of the four, as the discussion puts it in paraphrase. And beyond the measured Balkans lies the larger unmeasured claim: the introduction reports it from northeast Italy, Hungary and the central Balkans and east through Anatolia and Crimea to the Caucasus and Iran, and the discussion states plainly that sampling in this study was restricted to the Balkans, so geographically structured variation in exactly this species may be insufficiently represented. No locality held it together with any other member of the complex.

So what does the most-measured species hold, when its own anchor could not be measured at all? Not a number at its centre — there is none. It holds by breadth at every level at once: the joint-largest sample and the largest nest count, the widest size range, the most localities, the widest waist measurements in the table, the broadest list of nest trees, the northernmost reach, the longest reported range, three sunk names re-confirmed beneath it at three different strengths of evidence, and a stand-in whose 0.945 does duty for the type’s silence. Each earlier page in this set found a name holding by one thing — a place, a narrowing, an inheritance, a proxy. This one holds by the sum. And the sum has the same unfinished edge as the parent’s did, turned east: the Balkans were measured; Anatolia, Crimea, the Caucasus and Iran were reported. Whether the widest name is still one animal at its eastern end is, like the parent’s Cyprus and Levant reports, future work — the place where the four-species sequence does not so much close as open.

The walk — five moments in one name’s breadth, schematic only. Click each stage.

a species, Vipava Valley, 1853
sunk, demoted, raised, sunk again
an anchor too damaged to measure
held by accumulation, 0.620 to 0.984
eleven localities measured, a range to Iran reported

Pick a stage.

Its sisters hold an island and a narrowed coast; the widest holds everything except a number of its own.