The mark that recruits by the opposite promise — a warning, a ban, a closing date
R818’s Agloe recruited because it promised a place: the name was there, so people came toward it. But a mark can recruit by promising the reverse. Say keep out, say nothing here, say this is about to be forbidden — and the repelling mark does the advertising. It names the thing, certifies that the thing is worth someone’s trouble to suppress, and tells everyone exactly where it is. Three different cases, three different mechanisms, one shape.
The removal that named it. In 2003 Barbra Streisand sued photographer Kenneth Adelman for $50 million over one aerial photograph — Image 3850, labelled with her Malibu estate — in the California Coastal Records Project, a public archive of some 12,000 coastline photographs made to document erosion. Before the suit, that image had been downloaded six times, twice by her own attorneys. In the month after the filing, more than 420,000 people visited the site. The suit was dismissed and she was ordered to pay Adelman’s legal fees. Two years later Mike Masnick coined a name for the shape: the Streisand effect. Note the precision the numbers demand: six downloads of the image before, against 420,000 visits to the site after — not the same measure, and the page does not pretend they are. Even so, the direction is not in doubt. The attempt to erase one frame from an archive of twelve thousand was the only advertisement that frame ever had, and the lawsuit itself supplied the label that told the crowd which frame to look at.
The ban that became a badge. From the late nineteenth century to the mid-twentieth, Boston’s officials and the Watch and Ward Society banned books, plays and films they found salacious — shows run out of town, screenings stopped mid-reel. The unintended consequence was a phrase: “banned in Boston” came to signal something lurid and worth seeking, and distributors were often pleased to earn it, because it raised a work’s appeal everywhere else. Some went further and advertised the badge for works Boston had not banned at all. That is the warning fully detached from any real closure: the claim of suppression, with no suppression behind it, still recruited — because the audience was not responding to the ban, it was responding to what a ban seemed to certify.
The closing date that filled the route. Uluru is the physical case, and the least comfortable one. The Anangu, its traditional owners, had long asked visitors not to climb the rock, which is sacred to them; over the years a growing majority of visitors honoured that, and the proportion who climbed fell below the thresholds the park board had set. In November 2017 the board — which has an Anangu majority — voted unanimously to close the climb on 26 October 2019, the anniversary of the handback of the land. Announcing a date turned a declining activity into a deadline. Parks Australia counted more than 395,000 visitors to the park in the twelve months to June 2019, about twenty percent more than the year before, and reporting from the final weeks described more than a thousand people a day lining up to climb before the gate shut — a rush that ran directly against the request the closure existed to honour. Two honest narrowings: the final surge coincided in part with school holidays, so the deadline was not its only cause; and the closure closed an activity, not the place — the board’s chair put it as not stopping tourism, just this activity. The place stayed open, and stayed visited. What the date emptied, it emptied only after first filling it one last time.
One quiet place, warned about three ways. A schematic toy, stated plainly. A place almost nobody has heard of starts with 6 looks and no arrivals. Leaving it alone adds almost nothing. Each public attempt to remove or forbid it multiplies the looks and converts some into arrivals — most onlookers are merely curious, a few actually come. Claiming the ban as a badge recruits even when no ban exists. Announcing a closing date produces one large final rush, and then the activity really does end: after closure, arrivals for it fall to zero, however famous the warning made it.
Agloe’s mark was a promise, and it recruited by being believed. These marks are warnings, and they recruit by being heard — belief is not even required. A warning is a peculiar kind of sign: to obey it you must first read it, and reading it gives you the name, the place, and the news that someone with authority thought it worth forbidding. Suppression has to publish what it suppresses, at least enough to identify it, and that minimum publication is already an advertisement with an official seal on it. The desire path recorded where people had already gone. The paper street waited to see if anyone would come. The warning goes further than either: it is a trace laid down by the people trying to prevent arrival, and it can out-recruit the place’s own name — six downloads, until somebody filed to make it nothing, and four hundred thousand people came to see the nothing for themselves.