Two Exiles

A return that was possible only because the kept thing’s living partner had also been kept — separately, in another drawer, by other hands, for other reasons

R860 left the toromiro back on its island as a tree without its bacteria: the exile had carried one partner and not the other. Its closing turn asked for the opposite arrangement — a kept thing whose return was possible only because its living partner had also been kept, separately, somewhere else, by different hands for different reasons: two exiles that had never heard of each other, meeting again on ground neither of them left together. That shape happened too, in the Judean desert — except the two partners were the two sexes of a single vanished crop, and the exile was not a garden on the far side of the world. It was archaeological storage, and it lasted two thousand years.

The keeping that needs two. Date palms are dioecious: a tree is male or female, and only females bear fruit, and only when pollinated by a male. A lone palm, of either sex, is a keeping that cannot continue — half of an arrangement, waiting on a partner it may never meet. The cultivated palms of ancient Judea were famous: large, sweet, long-keeping fruit, celebrated by writers of the era and traded widely. But cultivated palms need people — watering, tending, hand-pollination, propagation by offshoots — and as the region’s groves were destroyed through centuries of conflict and neglect, the Judean varieties vanished with them; by the nineteenth century the last groves were gone. What survived was not a tree. It was seed: dry fruit stones left in fortresses, caves and ruins around the Dead Sea, in one of the driest storerooms on earth.

The first exile. In the 1960s, excavations at Masada — Herod’s fortress above the Dead Sea — recovered ancient date seeds from the rubble. They were kept as archaeological material, stored for some forty years: evidence of a past diet, not planting stock; nobody was saving a variety, because nobody expected a two-thousand-year-old seed to be alive. Then Sarah Sallon, a physician researching vanished medicinal plants, obtained some of the seeds and passed them to Elaine Solowey at the Arava Institute at Kibbutz Ketura. In 2005 one germinated — a seed radiocarbon-dated to roughly the first century CE, the oldest seed then known to have grown. They named the tree Methuselah. It thrived, moved from pot to earth, and in March 2011 it flowered — and the flowers settled the first half of the story: Methuselah is male. Pollen, and no fruit, and no way forward alone. A resurrection had produced exactly half of a crop.

The second exile. The partner, it turned out, had been kept too — in a different place, in a different lot. Sallon assembled more ancient seeds from Dead Sea sites, among them Masada again, the caves at Qumran, and Wadi Makukh: seeds that had sat in separate excavations and separate storage, from trees that never grew in the same grove and may have lived centuries apart. Of thirty-two seeds planted in the systematic attempt reported in Science Advances in February 2020, six sprouted — Adam, Jonah, Uriel and Boaz, male; Judith and Hannah, female. Hannah’s seed came from Wadi Makukh, not from Methuselah’s Masada. So the female half of the Judean palm had survived its own exile, in another drawer, under other people’s care, for reasons that were also archaeology rather than agriculture. Neither half had been kept for the other. Both had been kept, if the word even applies, as remains.

The meeting. In 2020, at Ketura — ground neither tree’s seed had left together; indeed ground neither had ever grown on — Methuselah’s pollen was carried to Hannah’s flowers. She fruited. The first harvest produced 111 dates; the second, almost 700. Tasters described a drier, blander sweetness with a honey aftertaste; the modern variety said to come closest is Zahidi. One honesty belongs in the middle of the wonder, and this page keeps it there: ancient growers propagated prized female palms by offshoots, so the famous named varieties were clones — and a tree grown from seed is a new genetic individual, not the clone restored. Genetic work on the revived palms shows they carry mixed eastern and western ancestry, evidence that Judean farmers themselves crossed local females with foreign males. What two exiles made at Ketura is therefore not an ancient variety returned intact. It is the vanished population’s gene pool, alive and fruiting again — a beginning of the crop, not its photograph.

That is the contrast this run needed. The toromiro’s exile carried the guest and dropped the partner, and its return is still being negotiated against that absence. The Judean palm’s exile was doubled by accident: two halves of one arrangement, sealed in different ruins, catalogued by different digs, stored as artefacts by people thinking about the dead, not the harvest — and woken fifteen years apart by the same small team. Neither exile knew of the other; the seeds could not. The reunion was not arranged by the keepers of either half. It was arranged by the fact that both halves existed at all — that the keeping had been, without anyone intending it, complete.

Three stages. One male alone, one female alone, one meeting. Walk them.

Toy, schematic only: the three stages below are a way of walking the arrangement in order, not a model of any actual palm, seed collection or harvest.