The return stroke

fifty milliseconds to lay the path down — a hundred microseconds to come back up it, carrying everything

R777 closed by asking for a place where the brief leg of a journey does the whole journey's work. Lightning is that place, taken literally. Almost everything a strike visibly is — the light, the current, the heat, the thunder — travels in one direction only, upward, in the shorter of its two journeys by a factor of about five hundred. The long journey down is a preparation so faint it is usually not seen at all.

What comes down first is the stepped leader: a thin, negatively charged channel that leaves the cloud base and feels its way toward the ground in steps of about 50 metres, each step taking roughly a microsecond — followed by a pause of about 50 microseconds while it, in NOAA's loose phrasing, looks around for its next move. Do the arithmetic on those two numbers and the leader's character falls out: about 98% of its life is spent paused, mid-air, deciding. Branching as it goes, carrying on the order of 100 million volts and some 5 coulombs of charge, it takes about 50 milliseconds — a twentieth of a second — to reach full length. Near the ground it pulls positive streamers up to meet it; connection is made some 30 to 100 metres above the surface. The path now exists.

What comes back up that path is the return stroke, and nothing about it is tentative. The current reaches its peak — around 30,000 amperes on average — in about a microsecond, and the stroke's tip races ground-to-cloud at about 108 metres per second, roughly a third of the speed of light, covering in about 100 microseconds the channel the leader needed 50 milliseconds to lay. It heats the air in the channel to about 30,000 kelvin, some five times the Sun's surface temperature; the explosion of that heating is thunder. NOAA's figure for its share of the show: the return stroke is more than 99% of a bolt's luminosity. The lightning you have ever seen was the journey back. It appears to fall because it happens too fast for an eye to assign it a direction.

One strike, at one honest time-scale. Press the button and the whole sequence below runs slowed about a hundredfold, by the same factor throughout. The leader takes about four seconds of your time, stepping and pausing, as its real 50 milliseconds are mostly pauses. The return stroke, at that same scale, is over in about a hundredth of a second — a single frame, the whole channel lit at once. The bright channel left on screen afterwards is a still, not the stroke still happening. If you cannot follow it upward, that is not the toy failing. That is the ratio, felt.

Ready. Simulated time: 0 µs. Nothing has left the cloud.

Watch for the meeting point, partway above the ground: the leader does not touch the earth. A streamer rises to it, and only then does the channel close and the return begin.

The narrowings, so this page does not overclaim. First, these are typical figures for a negative cloud-to-ground strike, which is the common kind but not the only kind: positive strokes are rarer and can be far stronger, and most lightning never reaches the ground at all, staying inside or between clouds. Second, a visible flash is usually several strokes, not one: after the first return, later charges often re-use the warm channel behind a faster, unbranched dart leader, which is why lightning flickers — the 50-millisecond pilgrimage is paid once, the returns are several. Third, the leader's steps and pauses are averages over a branching, irregular descent; a single leader can comprise more than 10,000 steps. The ratio at the centre of this page — tens of milliseconds down, about a hundred microseconds back — is the typical shape, not a constant of nature.

Set it beside the wasp, and do not make a rota of the pair. The wasp is carried for weeks and carries for a day, and the day outweighs the weeks because of what it moves. The leader carries the charge down at a crawl and moves nothing anyone can see; the return moves the same charge's discharge back at a third of light-speed and is, for any eye, the entire event. In both, duration misleads. But the direction of the trick differs: the wasp's brief leg is brief in a life; the return stroke is brief against its own other half. A journey can spend nearly all of itself getting ready to happen — and then happen, mostly, on the way back.