The same epithet, the same author, the same year — but this one was born where the code could see it, so it kept its priority, its authorship and its types for 115 years, and has just lost two thirds of its map anyway
R1000 followed the ionia that never legally existed. This page follows its twin. In the same 1911 work, a few pages later, Forel used the epithet again — this time for an ant in a different genus. Everything below is summarised in my own words, with no quoted text beyond bare collecting and bibliographic data.
First, the birth was legal. Forel published it in 1911 at page 340 as a variety of Crematogaster scutellaris — three names deep, at a rank the naming code of that era could register, in pointed contrast to the four-names-deep variety under smyrnensis on page 336. So this ionia was available from birth: it carries Forel’s authorship and 1911 date with real priority, and its original specimens are genuine types. In 1987 Agosti and Collingwood raised it to full species, and Crematogaster ionia has stood in current use ever since.
Second, its types were scattered from the start. The original series came from widely separated places, all listed in the 1911 account and retold by the recent revision: two localities near Smyrna and the Ayvalık peninsula material — noted in the account as taken in the Ayvalık wood pile carried to Smyrna, the same timber setting that carried the other ionia’s first record — then Izmit in Bithynia, Kifissia near Athens, Patras, and Corfu. That spread crosses what are now understood to be two species’ ranges. An available name is anchored by its types; this one was anchored, from day one, in two countries’ worth of ground at once.
Third, for a century the species was held together mostly by colour. As a sensu lato it was mapped across the southern Balkan mainland, most or all Greek islands, the southwestern half of Anatolia, Cyprus, and the coast southeast to Israel, recognised by a fairly uniform dark brown colouring. The recent revision states plainly, in paraphrase, that no morphometric key separated it from the bicoloured C. schmidti — telling them apart rested on subjective colour judgement — and that extra, still-undescribed entities had repeatedly been suspected inside it, with doubtful material pragmatically filed under ionia anyway. Priority protected the name. Nothing protected its contents.
Fourth, measured at last, it was three. The East Mediterranean revision of the scutellaris complex measured 201 workers from 68 nests, and the clustering resolved what had been filed as ionia sensu lato into three distinct entities: a Cretan species, newly described as C. ariadnae; a Greek mainland and North Macedonian species, newly described as C. graeca; and ionia in the strict sense, the cluster from Samos, Karpathos and Rhodes together with Anatolia. The strict species is separated in the new key largely by measurement — among other traits it carries the complex’s highest index for the length of the fine hairs on the first gastral segment. Its verified distribution in the revision is seven localities on those three islands and at Smyrna.
Fifth, keeping the name meant narrowing it — by an argument, not just a measurement. Faced with a mixed original series, the revisers argued for giving precedence to the Anatolian animal, on the ground that the epithet itself comes from Ionia, the historical west coast of Anatolia. The Smyrna syntype (FOCOL1448, Berlin) was run as a wild card in their analysis and landed with the Samos–Karpathos– Rhodes cluster, at a modest probability. A Patras syntype (CASENT0908491), by contrast, landed with the mainland cluster at near certainty and was excluded from the type series; it now appears in the revision under graeca’s distribution, still labelled as a syntype of ionia. And the narrowing is not finished: the revision notes that no material from east of Rhodes was measured, though the species has been reported from Cyprus and the Levant, so those populations’ place in the new arrangement is untested.
So what does an available name hold? The rights, not the unity. It held priority, so no later name could displace it. It held authorship, so every use for 115 years cited the same man and year. It held types, so the question of what it means could in principle always be settled by going back to pinned specimens — and when the settling finally came, the types were exactly where the trouble was: they spanned two species, and the name survived only by being cut down to the part of its own birthplace that matched its etymology. Its unavailable twin lost nothing in 2023, because it owned nothing; the available twin kept its name, its author and its date, and lost Crete and the mainland. Legality and stability, which came completely apart for the twin that had no rights, turn out to be separate things for the twin that had them all, too.
The walk — five moments in an available name’s working life, schematic only. Click each stage.
Pick a stage.
Its twin kept a whole past while owning nothing. This one owned everything a name can own — and the first rigorous look at what it owned divided it by three.