Crematogaster scutellaris read whole — the excluded fifth, the western species the whole complex is named for, present in the eastern revision only as a synonymy sink and a gene-flow leak, and everywhere else as the animal other species copy
R1010 read the Cretan sister, R1011 the mainland daughter, R1012 the narrowed parent and R1013 the widest of the four. This page steps outside that set to the one species all four were filed under, told apart from, or darkened by — and which the 2026 revision of the Crematogaster scutellaris complex deliberately did not measure, because its ground is the west. Reading it whole does not break the sequence’s one-paper discipline so much as complete it: the revision’s own introduction already sketches this animal, and the papers beyond it supply the living body the sketch points at. Everything below is summarised in my own words, with no quoted text beyond bare collecting and bibliographic data.
First, the animal in the sketch. Crematogaster scutellaris (Olivier, 1792) was described from France. In the revision’s introduction it is a West Mediterranean species: Northwest Africa and Iberia, the Balearic Islands, southern France and mainland Italy, Sardinia, Corsica and Sicily, Istria, most Croatian islands, and the Dalmatian mainland coast southwards only as far as the latitude of the island of Hvar — the line where schmidti’s Dalmatia begins. It typically carries a reddish head while the rest of the body is blackish, and its workers and gynes are larger than those of the other species of the complex. Note what that colour pattern is not: it is not schmidti’s reddish mesosoma and waist. The one red part stays at the front; everything behind it is dark. The complex bears this species’ name, and the revision of its eastern members still begins by placing it — and then sets it aside, on zoogeographic grounds, as outside the study area.
Second, the roof it held over eastern names. Twice over, the measured four began life filed under this one. Schmidti was moved into Crematogaster and sunk as a junior synonym of scutellaris in 1855, demoted to a subspecies of scutellaris by Forel in 1904, and sunk under it again in 1961, between its raisings. Ionia began in 1911 as Forel’s variety of scutellaris, collected from Smyrna to Patras. For a century, then, the west held the east in its synonymy: to be a doubtful eastern ant was, again and again, to be filed as a form of this western one. The 2026 revision is, among other things, an emptying of that roof — every name it raises is a name taken back out from under scutellaris.
Third, the leak that runs the other way. Excluded from the measurement, the species is still inside one of the measured files as a cause. Northwestern schmidti workers sometimes carry a blackish mesosoma and waist, and the revision’s account states that this is a consequence of introgression from C. scutellaris — gene flow from the western species darkening the eastern one until the eastern one’s own colour signature fails. The introduction adds that a morphometric differentiation between the two is nonetheless possible and that their introgression has been investigated; the discussion, as R1013 recorded, proposes western and eastern refugia behind their split. So the boundary the revision draws on geography is real in the measurements and porous in the genes, at the same edge, at the same time.
Fourth, the living animal the eastern file never meets. A 2024 study of its trail pheromone calls it, in paraphrase, the most widespread arboreal ant in the Mediterranean area, reaching north to Südtirol in Italy, and one of the most highly-ranked competitors in Mediterranean ant communities. Its colonies are usually monogynous, can live for over twenty years and reach up to 20,000 workers, and it colonises and excavates cavities in trees, dead wood and galls. Its trails are not laid from the gaster, as in most ants, but from glands in the hind tibias — and when that secretion was analysed, it held a single unique peak: the alcohol 2-tridecanol. Separated into its two mirror forms, the R form moved ants at concentrations roughly a thousand times lower than the S form, whose weak effect at high doses the authors attribute to a trace of the R form left in the sample; the exact ratio the ant itself produces could not be determined from the little extract available. The same ants also follow 2-dodecanol, the trail pheromone of the fully allopatric African relative C. castanea, which they do not produce themselves — a signal recognised across a separation, by a species that has never met its sender.
Fifth, what it keeps, and who copies it. In an Italian oak forest, a 2021 study surveyed 130 Andricus kollari galls: 29 were colonised by scutellaris, in the highest galls on the trees (a mean of about 2.97 m), and eleven of those gall nests held live aphids of the non-gall species Panaphis juglandis — three to five with a lone queen, six to eleven where workers and brood were present, and never in a gall without this ant. Experiments indicated the ants actively seek, collect and stock the aphids alive; no predation or injury was found on the stored animals, which were probably kept for safe overwintering, occasional use as food not excluded. And on its foraging trails, other species arrange themselves around it: a 2024 Tunisian study describes it as an ecologically and behaviourally dominant ant whose large permanent trails are pugnaciously defended by biting and spraying a toxic secretion, and as a visual mimicry model for various other organisms — reporting the first Tunisian records of the mimicking ant Colobopsis imitans and identifying the mirid bug Mimocoris rugicollis as another mimic, both found following or stationing near its trails, often with a third mimic, Camponotus lateralis — the same follower named in the trail lists of all four eastern species. To be this ant is to be worth copying: its colours are a shelter other animals wear.
Sixth, the edge that will not stay put. The western species is also moving. In spring 2022 the first outdoor nest ever recorded in Belgium was found at Rood Klooster in Auderghem, Brussels — large, very active trails in a hedge and along a small building’s walls, the nest probably already several years old and situated in the building’s wooden construction, well north of the Mediterranean world the revision assigns it to. The reporters judged, from its interactions with local ants, that it would not immediately become an invasive problem, and expected more records nearby and elsewhere in the country. The excluded fifth, in other words, is not staying inside its own exclusion either.
The claim of this page: scutellaris holds by being the model. The complex is named for it; two of the four eastern names were once filed under it and had to be taken back out; the fourth eastern boundary is darkened by its genes; unrelated ants and a bug copy its colours to travel its trails; and even its own trail signal is a single molecule other Crematogaster recognise. The revision could leave it unmeasured precisely because so much else is measured against it. A model does not need a row in the table. It is the thing the table is about.
The walk — five moments in one name’s modelling, schematic only. Click each stage.
Pick a stage.
Its eastern relatives hold an island, a narrowed coast and the widest span. The model holds the position everything else is copied from, or measured against, or filed under — and is now nesting north of where any of them drew it.