Still in the burrow

Keeping done by an address — a Manx shearwater chick waiting out its whole season alone at the end of one burrow in a colony of thousands, while its parents come and go from the sea, only ever in the dark

R924 closed with a chick that had to be picked out of a crowd by a voice, because it could wander and there was no nest to address a meal to. This page takes the turn it offered, to the opposite arrangement. Here the chick never wanders at all. It hatches underground, at the end of a tunnel, and it stays there — growing, for a while, to heavier than either of its parents — while everything it eats is carried in from hundreds of kilometres of ocean, at night, to one hole among thousands of near-identical holes. No voice has to sort this chick out of a crowd. It has never been in a crowd. The place does the sorting, if the parent can find the place.

The bird, and the burrow. The Manx shearwater, Puffinus puffinus, is a tube-nosed seabird of the North Atlantic, and most of the world’s population breeds around Britain and Ireland, on offshore islands where the ground can be honeycombed with burrows. Skomer, off Wales, is one of the great colonies; counts there have been put at over a hundred thousand pairs in some censuses and far higher in others, so the honest figure is a range across surveys and years, not a number. The nest is the burrow itself: commonly about a metre or two long in the field-guide accounts, dug by both parents or taken over from a rabbit, sometimes reused in later years, ending in a chamber with a scant lining of grass and leaves. Onto that chamber floor goes a single white egg. Everything about the colony’s life on land happens at night, and for a plain reason: the adults are clumsy on the ground and large gulls hunt them there. By day the island can look almost empty of shearwaters. The birds are either under it, or out at sea.

The long shifts, then the longer wait. Incubation runs about fifty-one days on average, in a reported range of roughly forty-seven to fifty-five, and it is done in turns that would look like neglect in almost any other bird: one parent sits in the dark for five to seven days at a stretch in the modern Skomer studies — spells averaging about six days, and occasionally far longer, in the older Skokholm work — fasting, while the other is at sea feeding, sometimes as far away as the Bay of Biscay. They change over during a nocturnal visit. When the chick hatches the pattern loosens but does not quicken. Both parents feed it, and still it is alone for most of its life: in the Skokholm breeding-biology study the chick received about two feeds in every three days, and a later begging study found the two parents running on different clocks — males returning at least once every four days with some regularity, females adjusting to the chick’s begging and staying away up to eight days when it was well fed. Fed on regurgitated fish and squid, the chick grows past its parents, reaching peak weights well above an adult’s, much of it fat. That fat is not excess. It is the budget for what comes last.

The return, and the hole in the dark. So state the parent’s problem exactly. It comes in off the sea in the middle of the night, to an island slope drilled with burrows, in a colony where the air on a busy dark night is full of raucous, cackling calls — the species is silent at sea and noisy only here. Its chick is invisible, underground, at the end of one particular tunnel. What gets it to that tunnel? The honest answer is layered, and the layers belong to different birds, which this page keeps apart. Place itself does most of it: pairs return to the same burrow year after year, and the classic Skomer accounts describe incoming birds being answered by calls from the birds underground, the exchange helping an arrival localise its hole — so voice is not absent here, but it is a voice from an address, not a voice searching a crowd. Smell is the other candidate, and the tube-noses are built for it, using scent over the ocean as well as on land; but the direct experiments are in close relatives, not in this species — Cory’s shearwaters made temporarily unable to smell homed back to their individual burrows significantly worse than untreated controls, blue petrels could identify their nest by olfactory cues alone, with the burrow’s scent formed largely by its owners’ own odour and stable across a season, and Scopoli’s shearwaters deprived of smell lost their orientation over open water yet still foraged and returned by sight near land. And then there is the finding that explains why the system can afford to be approximate about everything except the hole: in burrowing storm petrels, a close relative in the same broad family of arrangements, researchers found no chick recognition at all, and the likely reason is that none is needed — a chick confined in a burrow cannot be confused with any other chick, so a parent that finds the right burrow has, by that one act, found the right young. Recognition has been replaced by real estate.

The desertion. The keeping ends the way it ran: without a ceremony, and before the young bird is ready. After about sixty days of feeding, the parents stop coming. The chick stays in the burrow alone for another eight or nine days, living on its fat, and only then — on the Audubon account’s figures, with the older studies putting leaving at about seventy days from hatching — does it emerge at night, exercise its wings above ground in the dark over several nights in the classic accounts, and go to sea entirely alone, untaught and unescorted, to begin a migration toward the South Atlantic that no parent will show it. The burrow’s whole bargain is now visible. Stillness bought the chick a season in which it never once had to be recognised: no signature call, no picked-out face, nothing but an address held perfectly steady while the parents solved the finding, night after night, from the sea side. The price is that the address is all it ever had — and the day it finally moves, it moves alone, and nobody is looking for it any more.

One chick’s season, in order: it hatches at the end of a burrow a metre or two long, in an island colony counted in the hundreds of thousands of pairs, from a single egg incubated about fifty-one days in fasting shifts of five to seven days; it sits alone underground while both parents forage at sea, in some studies hundreds of kilometres away, fed about two nights in three, growing heavier than its parents on stored fat; each return is made in darkness, to one hole among thousands, by some layering of remembered place, calls answered from underground, and — on evidence from close relatives — the burrow’s own scent; because the chick cannot leave, the parent never has to recognise it, only the address; and at about sixty days the visits simply stop, the chick fasting eight or nine days more on its fat before emerging at night and leaving for the sea alone. Schematic, compressed from the published record.

Walk it in order.

Schematic only: the stages compress one chick’s season, and real timings vary by colony, pair and year. Labelled cautions: Skomer’s size is kept as a range across censuses — over a hundred thousand pairs in some, far higher in others — and must not be quoted as one settled number, nor merged with the counts for Skokholm or Rùm; burrow length is the field guides’ usual range, and many burrows are inherited from rabbits rather than dug; incubation of about fifty-one days and shifts of five to seven days are averages with wide reported spreads, the longest spells far beyond the average; the two-feeds-in-three-days figure and the peak chick weights rest chiefly on the Skokholm study of the 1960s, and the two parents’ different return clocks on one begging study — neither is a law for every burrow; the moonlight picture is likewise mixed, classic Skomer accounts reporting far fewer and quieter arrivals on bright nights while the Skokholm study found breeding birds’ visits, unlike non-breeders’, not affected by the moon, so this page claims only that colony life is nocturnal, not that every return waits for a moonless night; the smell evidence is explicitly from other tube-nosed species — Cory’s and Scopoli’s shearwaters and blue petrels — and must not be retold as a proved Manx result; and “no chick recognition” is a finding from burrowing storm petrels, offered here as the likeliest reading of this arrangement, not as a test anyone has run on a Manx chick.