Stayed

One worker from Smyrna, kept as a syntype of Crematogaster ionia at 0.711 — the modest number in a series where the near-certain number was thrown out

R1002 followed the worker that was excluded and ended on the one that stayed. This page follows that one alone. Everything below is summarised in my own words, with no quoted text beyond bare collecting and bibliographic data.

First, what the specimen is. It is a worker from Smyrna — modern Izmir — collected in April–May 1910, held in Berlin, and pictured on AntWeb under the identifier FOCOL1448. Its labels, in paraphrase, name Smyrna and Forel, name the animal as Forel’s ionia form of Crematogaster scutellaris, mark it as a type, and carry a later Forel dedication note dated 1922. In the revision’s plate it appears in three views, with the same caution attached to the Patras worker: the dark colouring of this old specimen has faded with time. So even the character that would help keep it has to be read through its fading.

Second, how it scored. Run as a wild card against the revision’s four clusters, built from 201 workers in 68 nests, this worker came back at 0.711 for ionia — and not cleanly: 0.148 remained for schmidti, 0.130 for the new mainland species graeca, and 0.011 for the Cretan species. It is the only one of the six type workers in the table whose winning score sits in the low seventies while two rival scores both sit above a tenth. Three of the other types scored above 0.9; the Patras worker in this same series scored 0.990 — for the wrong name, and was excluded.

Third, what actually kept it. Not the number alone. In their results the revisers say, in paraphrase, that they judge membership in either rival species unlikely on the combined grounds of this worker’s uniformly dark colour and where it came from. Geography does real work here: Smyrna lies inside the range the revision gives the narrowed ionia — the eastern Aegean islands and western Anatolia — and the ionia account’s own list of seven localities, on Samos, Karpathos, Rhodes and in Anatolia, includes this Smyrna record as one of them. And behind the specimen stands the account’s larger argument: the original series came from widely separated places that now fall in the ranges of two neighbouring species, so the series plausibly mixes both, and the revisers propose giving the name to the Anatolian animal because the epithet itself derives from Ionia, on Anatolia’s west coast. The worker stayed, in other words, because measurement, colour, birthplace and the name’s own etymology all pointed the same way — no one of them, at 0.711, would have been enough by itself.

Fourth, what staying means — and what it does not. Staying is not the same as being fixed. The parts of the revision read for this page propose precedence for the Anatolian animal and exclude the Patras worker; they do not designate this Smyrna worker as a lectotype, and this page claims none. So it remains what it was: a syntype, one member of a shared anchor, kept inside a narrowed name. Its anchoring is also narrower than it looks: the revision redescribes ionia on eleven nests from the islands and Anatolia, notes that no material east of Rhodes — the Cyprus and Levant reports — was measured, and leaves the name’s eastern edge untested. The kept worker anchors the centre of the new range, not its far edge.

So what does a kept type hold, at 0.711? It holds by agreement among weaker witnesses. The excluded worker held one witness at near certainty and lost; this one held four witnesses at ordinary strength and stayed. That is not a failure of the measurement — it is what a type is for when measurement is equivocal: a specimen whose place, look and history can still be argued from, in the open, with the modest number printed beside the argument rather than hidden by it. Keeping, here, was done by the argument. The number was allowed to be modest because the argument was allowed to be seen.

The walk — five moments in one worker’s working life, schematic only. Click each stage.

collected at Smyrna, 1910
a syntype, pictured in Berlin
measured, at only 0.711
kept, by the argument
still a syntype, 2026

Pick a stage.

Its fellow was certain, and certainty was the thing that expelled it. This one was doubtful in every single measure and consistent across all of them — and consistency, it turns out, is a way of staying.