The Stand-In

A return completed by a substitute — the original partner was never kept anywhere, so a different species was recruited to play the missing part, and the work got done by a dancer who is not the one who left

R861 closed on a clean contrast. Methuselah and Hannah were both originals: two genuine halves of the Judean date palm, kept whole in different ruins, meeting again at Ketura. Its closing turn asked for the messier arrangement underneath that one — a kept thing whose original partner was never kept at all, anywhere, and whose return was completed instead by a stand-in: a relative, a substitute, a different species recruited to play the missing part, where the reunion is real, the work gets done, and yet one of the dancers is not the one who left. That shape happened off Mauritius, and the thing waiting for its partner was not an animal. It was a forest.

The partner that was never kept. Mauritius and its offshore islets were once home to endemic giant tortoises of the genus Cylindraspis — on Mauritius itself, C. inepta and C. triserrata. They were the islands’ large browsers, grazers and seed dispersers: big, slow fruit-eaters under whose feet and through whose guts the native forest renewed itself. They were not collected into safety, bred in a garden, or sealed in a drawer. They were eaten and extirpated, gone from the Mascarenes between the early 1700s and the mid-1800s; the Mauritian Wildlife Foundation records the last wild endemic tortoise as collected on Round Island in 1844. No exile population survived. Unlike Methuselah’s seed, there was no second drawer. The partner part in the arrangement simply ended.

The kept thing, waiting. On Ile aux Aigrettes, a 25-hectare islet off Mauritius, the slow-growing ebony Diospyros egrettarum once formed forest and is now critically endangered. Intensive logging for firewood, lasting until the early 1980s, cut it back hard. Then came the telling fact: in the decades after logging stopped, the cleared ground did not refill. A survey in 2007 mapped 3,518 adult ebony trees on the island, yet large tracts — especially the northern and eastern coasts nearest the mainland, where logging had been heaviest — stayed denuded. The trees that remained could make fruit and seed perfectly well. What they could not do was move: with the native giant tortoises extinct, no large fruit-eating animal was left to carry ebony seed away from the parent tree and plant it, gut-passed, somewhere new. The forest was a keeping with one dancer. It stood still for thirty years after the axes left, not because it was dying, but because its partner was not coming back.

The recruitment. In 2000, conservationists did the thing the date-palm keepers never had to consider: they hired a replacement. Aldabra giant tortoises, Aldabrachelys gigantea — giant tortoises from the Aldabra atoll in the Seychelles, a different species in a different genus, wild only there — were introduced to Ile aux Aigrettes expressly as taxon substitutes: exotic stand-ins meant to fulfil the seed-dispersal function the extinct Cylindraspis had performed. The method has a plain name in the literature, rewilding with taxon substitutes, and it is openly controversial: deliberately introducing an exotic species is normally the harm restoration exists to undo. The first captive animals were moved out of quarantine in late 2000, and by late 2004 the tortoises were roaming the islet freely; later work extended the same replacement to Round Island.

The work, done by the wrong tortoise. The stand-ins did the job. Reporting in Current Biology on 21 April 2011, Christine Griffiths and colleagues presented what they described as the first empirical evidence that this kind of rewilding can work: the Aldabra tortoises ate the large ebony fruits in quantity, dispersed large numbers of seeds across the islet, and passage through a tortoise gut improved the seeds’ germination — so new ebony seedlings established widely in exactly the heavily logged areas that had shown no regeneration for decades. Parallel feeding work with another endangered Mauritian tree, Syzygium mamillatum, whose fruits were likewise rotting undispersed, found the same pattern: seedlings from gut-passed seed grew taller and suffered less damage than comparison seedlings. The interaction the forest evolved with — large fruit, large tortoise, seed carried away and scarified in transit — is running again on Ile aux Aigrettes. Every step of it is real. None of the tortoises performing it is a Mauritian tortoise.

That is the distinction this page exists to hold apart from R861’s. At Ketura, the reunion was between survivors: changed, seed-grown, not the ancient clones, but continuous with the vanished grove by descent. On Ile aux Aigrettes there is no continuity of descent on the animal side at all. The ebony is original; its partner is a casting decision. The substitute was not even kept for this — Aldabra’s tortoises were simply still alive elsewhere, on their own atoll, available to be recruited because their own island had kept them. And the honesty condition runs the other way from Lascaux: there, a copy quietly took the original’s name; here, nobody pretends the stand-in is the original. The papers call it a substitute in their titles. The forest does not care what it is called — which is precisely the unease. A function can be fully restored by a stranger, and the restored system will look, from the seedlings up, exactly like a reunion. Only the record says otherwise: one of the dancers is not the one who left, and the one who left left nothing behind to come back as.

Three stages. The original partner, the waiting tree, the stand-in. Walk them.

Toy, schematic only: the three stages below are a way of walking the arrangement in order, not a model of any actual tortoise, tree population or restoration programme.