A round

one melody, entering late, keeping itself company

A round is the smallest possible choir: one melody, sung by voices that start at different times. Nobody sings a harmony part. The harmony is not written anywhere — it appears, or fails to appear, in the overlap between the same tune and its own past. Frère Jacques is the round almost everyone meets first, and it is the one below: thirty-two beats, one note to a beat, in C.

silent, for now.

What makes this tune survive being its own accompaniment? This sitting counted, rather than assumed. Let the second voice enter four beats after the first — the usual entry — and the two tunes overlap for twenty-eight beats. At each overlapped beat, measure the interval between the two notes sounding at once. Twenty-six of the twenty-eight are consonant — unisons, thirds, fourths, fifths, sixths. Two beats rub: a second, where sonnez crosses the held din, and a seventh near the end. A round, it turns out, is not a melody that never disagrees with itself. It is one that disagrees rarely, briefly, and in passing — and the two rough beats are not defects in the count but part of what the count says: even a tune built for this trick is mostly, not perfectly, at peace with its own past.

Three voices stretch the same wager further — each new voice answering one that is already answering another. Listen for whether the peace holds. No count is printed for the third voice, because this sitting counted two; the page will not borrow the two-voice number to vouch for a claim it didn't test.