Played by someone

Keeping when the giver is gone but his part is still played — an all-female whiptail lizard whose females court and mount one another in turn, and are reported to breed better for it

R935 closed with a colony that had abolished the giver in every role. This page takes the turn it offered and keeps the abolition while restoring the act. Here there is still no male, no sperm and no fertilisation — but the courtship that used to belong to a male has not been dropped. It has been taken over, by the other female, on a schedule set by her own ovaries.

A species made by crossing, then left female-only. The example is the desert grassland whiptail, Aspidoscelis uniparens (older literature: Cnemidophorus uniparens), a small, long-tailed lizard of desert grassland in southern and central Arizona, along the Rio Grande in New Mexico, and in northern Mexico. Every individual is female. In the account summarised here it arose from a cross between two sexual species, A. inornata and A. burti, producing a diploid all-female form, which then backcrossed with A. inornata to give the triploid A. uniparens. It is one of many parthenogenetic whiptails — the genus holds at least thirteen such species, all tracing to hybrid events between sexual relatives — and its sexual ancestors are still alive, which is what lets researchers compare the behaviour directly.

Eggs without fertilisation, diversity kept. The lizards reproduce by parthenogenesis: an egg develops without ever meeting sperm. The chromosome problem that would normally halve the set is met by doubling — summaries of the work describe eggs gaining a doubled chromosome complement, and in this triploid form chromosomes sitting in triplets that pair with their own copies rather than with unlike counterparts. The result, stated carefully, is offspring that are essentially copies of their mother, produced without a father, while a measure of the genetic variety inherited from the original hybrid cross is preserved rather than shuffled away. No giver contributes anything to an egg here — not genes, not a trigger stored from an earlier mating.

Two roles, swapped by the cycle. What was first described in the laboratory work of David Crews and Kevin Fitzgerald (1980), and followed up in Crews, Grassman and Lindzey (1986), is that paired females still go through a courtship and mounting sequence closely resembling copulation in their sexual relatives — ending in the curled posture the researchers called the doughnut — with one animal in the male-typical mounting role and the other in the female-typical receptive role, and no intromission or sperm transfer at all. Which animal plays which part is not fixed by size, age or dominance for life. It alternates with the ovarian cycle: a female approaching ovulation, with large follicles, is receptive; a female past ovulation takes the male-like role. Later summaries tie the male-like behaviour to high progesterone in the postovulatory phase, with hormone levels broadly following the pattern seen in the sexual ancestors but the brain responding to them in a way the parthenogen has evolved for itself. In one body, at different weeks, both parts are available.

Played, and useful. The behaviour is not a leftover with no effect, on the record summarised here. Pseudosexual behaviour is reported to enhance fecundity: in the review literature the mounted animal reaches ovulation sooner, and female–female courtship is described as inducing or enhancing ovulation in the receptive partner. That is the plausible reason the trait has persisted in a lineage that no longer needs it to obtain sperm — the performance still does reproductive work, even though its original genetic transaction is gone. Set this beside R935: there the termites dropped the male and dropped nothing else they needed, because they had never needed his behaviour. Here the whiptails dropped the male and kept his behaviour, because the behaviour itself, divorced from any male, still shortened the road to an egg.

One Aspidoscelis uniparens pair, in order: the species is all female and triploid, arising from a hybrid cross and a backcross between sexual whiptail relatives; its eggs develop by parthenogenesis after a chromosome doubling, with no fertilisation; paired females still court and mount in a sequence resembling their sexual relatives’ copulation, with no sperm transferred; the mounting, male-typical role is taken by the postovulatory female and the receptive role by the female approaching ovulation, so the same animal plays both parts across her cycle; and the performance is reported to enhance fecundity, the mounted female reaching ovulation sooner. Schematic, compressed from the published record.

Walk it in order.

Schematic only: the stages compress species-level and laboratory findings, and real cycles shift with animal and condition. Labelled cautions: the hybrid parentage above is the account given for A. uniparens specifically — other parthenogenetic whiptails have other sexual parents, and older papers use the genus name Cnemidophorus for the same animals; the fecundity claim is that pseudocopulation enhances ovulation and reproduction, not that a female kept entirely alone can never lay — isolated females are a separate comparison and this page does not put a number on it; “clone” is shorthand for near-copy offspring, not a claim that no genetic change ever occurs; and the progesterone link is a correlation reported in the literature, stated here as such, not as a complete mechanism.