a traffic jam that exists only between the cars
Every driver knows the shape of it: the motorway slows, stops, crawls, stops again — and when the road finally opens, there is nothing there. No crash, no works, no merge. You were held up, for twenty minutes, by an event with no location and no remains.
In 2008 a team led by Yuki Sugiyama at Nagoya University recreated that event on purpose, in its purest possible form: 22 cars on a single-lane circular track, 230 metres around, drivers asked only to hold a steady 30 km/h and keep a safe distance. No junctions, no lights, nothing to react to. Within about a minute the even spacing began to wobble, the wobble grew, and a cluster of cars was stopping outright — while a vehicle escaping the front of the cluster at up to 40 km/h was replaced by another joining its back. The jam itself travelled backwards around the ring at roughly 20 km/h, against the direction every car in it was driving. It was still there, circulating, long after whatever first tremor started it had been forgotten by everyone involved.
warming up…
The ring above is a simple car-following model (the Intelligent Driver Model) with the experiment's own numbers — 22 cars, 230 metres — plus a whisper of random noise in every driver's right foot. Nobody is programmed to cause a jam. Leave it running and watch the speeds: green is moving, red is stopped. Notice that the red patch drifts backwards, car to car, while each car in it is only ever moving forwards or standing still. The jam is not any of the cars. It is a wave in the spaces between them.
Why does a tremor grow instead of dying away? Each driver responds to the car ahead a moment late, and responds a little too much: the car behind brakes slightly harder than the car in front did, arrives slightly closer, and hands a slightly larger slowdown back down the line. Below a critical density the amplification is less than one and wobbles fade. Above it, each car faithfully passes on more than it received — and the wave becomes a thing in its own right, with its own speed, its own persistence, even its own direction: backwards, at a rate set by the traffic rather than by any driver. Later ring experiments with a single smoothly driven automated car among the human drivers (Stern and colleagues, 2018) found that one car which refuses to amplify — holding a steady pace and a generous gap — can absorb the waves around a whole ring. The phantom has an opposite: not a faster car, but a calmer one.
This track has lately met things assembled in odd places: a tear gas that exists only when a knife breaks an onion's inner walls, a third tone manufactured inside the listener's own ear. The phantom jam is the third address. It is not assembled in the source — no driver makes it, and each one is behaving reasonably. It is not assembled in a receiver — there is no single place it arrives. It is assembled on the way, in the passing-on itself, and it exists exactly as long as the handing-back continues. Stop the traffic entirely and it vanishes without a trace, like a rumour in a room that has emptied: everyone who carried it can honestly say it was never theirs.
Sources: New Scientist (2008), shockwave traffic jam recreated for the first time · Innovations Report (2008) on Sugiyama et al., New Journal of Physics 10, 033001