No Line Left

Keeping as a border that vanished — an introduced ant whose workers accept strangers from nests kilometres, then continents, away as nestmates, because the recognition that once drew a line around every small colony stopped drawing lines almost anywhere inside the supercolony

R951 closed with clones that recognised sameness only well enough to leave their own alone and fight everyone else, holding empty rock between them at tidal rhythm. This page takes the turn it pointed to, to the case where the fighting stops. The Argentine ant, Linepithema humile, is native to the Paraná River lowlands of South America. There it is ordinary in one respect: separate nests are separate colonies, genetically distinct from one another, and workers from nests only a few hundred metres apart can meet with systematic aggression. Carried by human shipping to Mediterranean climates on every continent except Antarctica, the same species reorganised. Keeping, here, is what happened to the line itself.

First, the unit is many nests, and it is not one colony in the household sense. An introduced supercolony is polydomous and polygynous: many physically separate nests, many queens, no single nest that is the capital and no queen whose brood the whole thing is. Workers and queens move freely among nests inside the unit, food and brood are not defended nest against nest, and there are no territorial boundaries between its nests at all. That absence has a name in the literature, unicoloniality. It does not mean one burrow grown huge. It means the question a worker normally answers at every foreign nest entrance — ours, or not ours? — comes back “ours” across the whole network.

Second, the scale is measured, not rhetorical. Along southern Europe, sampling over some 6,000 kilometres of coast found essentially two units: a main supercolony running from Italy to the Spanish Atlantic coast, made of millions of nests and, by the original estimate, billions of workers, and a much smaller Catalonian supercolony in eastern Spain. In California the large supercolony runs hundreds of kilometres up the coast. Later behavioural and chemical work linked the largest European, Californian and Japanese supercolonies to one another: workers from them meet with little or no aggression and carry closely similar recognition profiles, so the biggest introduced populations behave, on the tests used, as one intercontinental society. Smaller supercolonies alongside them do not get that welcome.

Third, the test is a meeting, and inside the line there is almost nothing to see. In pairwise encounters, workers from the same supercolony — even from distant, measurably differentiated populations — do not fight, and they antennate one another no more often than workers from the same nest do, as if the stranger were not registering as a stranger at all. Put two workers from different supercolonies together and the same assay turns lethal: in the European trials, fighting between the two units ended in a death in nearly every trial. So the border has not softened into a gradient. Inside, it is gone; at the edge of the unit, it is as hard as any border in the native range — field work in California found the clashes concentrated exactly there, between neighbouring nests of different supercolonies, with distance by itself predicting nothing.

Fourth, why the line vanished is genuinely split, and this page keeps it split. Recognition in ants rides largely on cuticular hydrocarbons, the waxy chemical profile a worker carries on her surface, and two accounts compete. The bottleneck account, built first on California, found the introduced ants carrying roughly half the genetic variation of native ones, consistent with descent from a small founding party: if everyone is similar enough, everyone passes the similarity test. The European work complicates that as a whole explanation: neutral genetic diversity there had fallen only modestly, populations inside the main supercolony were still considerably differentiated at neutral markers, and aggression tracked supercolony membership rather than overall genetic distance. Its authors proposed instead a selective narrowing at the recognition cues themselves — variation at the signal pruned away after introduction, each supercolony settling on a different version, while the rest of the genome stayed varied. Later diet experiments weigh against a purely environmental reading: feeding different supercolonies alike in the field did not dissolve their hostility or move their profiles onto one another. What is settled is the behaviour and the chemical correlation; which narrowing did it, and how much of each, is not settled, and the two famous cases may not share one history.

Last, set this beside R951 and the inversion is again exact, with a bill attached. Anthopleura spent recognition on defence and paid for its border in gonads and growth at the edge. The supercolony spends nothing on internal borders at all, and that saving is widely read as its ecological weapon: with no energy lost to fighting its own kind, it reaches worker densities that displace native ants many times its workers’ size. The paradox the literature keeps naming is that cooperation here is not underwritten by kinship: inside a supercolony, nestmates are effectively unrelated, so a worker raising brood is usually raising strangers’ offspring — the arrangement theory expects to be unstable, and may yet prove temporary. And the line has not left the species. It moved, from every nest, to the one edge where two supercolonies meet.

A walk from many lines to one. Five stages: a native river plain of small colonies that fight their neighbours; a small founding party carried overseas by shipping; the recognition cue narrowed, by bottleneck, by selection at the signal, or by both in different places; strangers from distant nests passing the nestmate test as if no test were being given; and the border reappearing, undiminished, only where two supercolonies touch. Schematic, compressed from the published accounts.

Walk it in order.

Schematic only: the stages compress native-range surveys, coastal sampling, laboratory encounter assays and chemical profiling, so no single nest runs this exact account. Labelled cautions: do not call a supercolony one nest, one colony with one queen, or a physically connected burrow — it is many separate nests with free movement and no internal territorial boundaries. Do not call its members close kin — relatedness inside is effectively near zero, which is the puzzle, not the explanation. Do not present the bottleneck as the proven single cause — the European data argue it is insufficient there, and the recognition-cue narrowing proposed in its place is a hypothesis with support, not a closed mechanism. Do not say diet or shared environment explains the truce — common rearing and field diet experiments left the hostility between supercolonies, and the peace within them, intact. Do not say the species has lost aggression — between supercolonies it is lethal, and it is at those edges that the fighting now happens. And do not merge the European, Californian and intercontinental results into one study: they are separate programmes, a decade apart, that agree on the behaviour.