Never Tested

The other name born in the same paper — a Greek ant described beside brackoi in 2019, believed ever since on that one paper’s morphology, while its tested sibling was let out of a wide name on complete measurement and an ambiguous genealogy

The last page was an escape: Temnothorax brackoi, filed for years as an approximation, named in 2019, and in 2024 put through an integrative revision that measured it completely apart. But brackoi was not the only name born in that paper. Ask what the other one holds — the one no revision has ever picked up.

First, it was born beside a name that would be tested, in a review that called itself preliminary. Salata and Borowiec published their division of the Greek Temnothorax in ZooKeys in October 2019: seventeen morphological groups proposed, and the aveli group reviewed with three members — the older turcicus, and two species new to science. Temnothorax messiniaensis was the second of those. Its range as described was narrower than its sibling’s from the start: the Ionian Islands and the Peloponnese, and nowhere else. Worker and gyne were figured, a diagnosis was given, and that — a single paper’s morphology — is the whole of the evidence the name has ever rested on.

Second, its own life is warm, south-western, and lived in dry stems. The later Greek faunistic notes repeat a steady picture in their own words: a species endemic to Greece, common in the Ionian Islands and the Peloponnese, favouring warm places — roadsides with Mediterranean shrubs, sunny forest edges — with nests inside the dry stems of shrubs and large herbs. It keeps its own colony, like its sibling. Nothing in the life separates the two names; what separated them was only that one of them later fell inside a complex someone decided to revise.

Third, the records kept arriving — and each one is a fresh bet on 2019. Western Greece notes logged it at a run of localities; the Peloponnese notes logged it again; an island comparison table marked it present on Zakynthos. Then the map began to creep: a paper on the Agrafa mountains announced it as new to Thessaly, and the 2026 Euboea account gives it a locality there, with a few records now from Sterea Ellas and Thessaly alongside its common south-western ground. Every one of those identifications was made against the 2019 description. The name is not idle while it waits: its map grows, its locality lists lengthen, and the amount that would have to be unwound if a test ever failed grows with them.

Fourth, its group was revisited — and it was kept, not tested. In 2025 Zięcina, Salata and Borowiec returned to the aveli group in Annales Zoologici, describing yet another new member, nebulosus, and publishing a fresh key to the group’s Greek members, messiniaensis among them. So the group has been re-keyed and enlarged since 2019. What no source checked for this page shows is anything like the treatment brackoi got: no molecular phylogenetics, no genealogical delimitation, no multivariate morphometric verdict on whether messiniaensis is one thing or several, or whether its boundary against its neighbours holds. Brackoi’s test arrived only because it had been swept into the unifasciatus complex’s revision. No such revision of the aveli group is on record in the sources checked. The name was retained by a key, which is a way of being believed again without being examined.

Fifth, no verdict of any other kind has arrived either. In the sources checked for this page, no conservation assessment for messiniaensis surfaced — the same absence its sibling and its wide neighbour carry. A Greek endemic, common where it is common, and uncounted by every institution that grades such things.

And so: is an untested name safer, or more exposed, than a tested one? Brackoi risked everything in 2024 and survived on split evidence — measurement complete, genealogy ambiguous. Messiniaensis has risked nothing, and so can point to nothing stronger than its birth certificate. It cannot be sunk by a test that has not run; it also cannot be confirmed by one. Meanwhile the bets compound quietly, locality by locality, each new record written in ink borrowed from a preliminary paper. The tested name knows what it survived. The untested one only knows what it has so far been spared.

A walk, schematic only — five stages, tap each one:

1 · born beside a tested name, 2019
2 · common in the south-west, in dry stems
3 · records creep east and north
4 · keyed again and kept, 2025
5 · still waiting for a first test

Described by Salata & Borowiec in 2019 (ZooKeys 877), in the preliminary aveli-group review, alongside brackoi; range as described: Ionian Islands and Peloponnese only.

Seven keepings, then, in a row: a name handed an island on loan, a name handed nothing and proved, a name born proved and never assessed, a name that keeps nothing of its own, the carrier underneath that one, the carrier’s escapee let out on an ambiguous index — and now the escapee’s sibling, which was never inside the cabinet at all and never needed letting out, because nobody has yet tried to put its name away either. The thread turns once more: a test is a risk a name can survive, but it is also the only way a name stops being a loan from its describers — and some names wait so quietly that the waiting itself starts to look like the verdict.