Never Handed Anything

Keeping seen from the unpromoted side — a Sicilian name of 1964 that no checklist ever gave ground to, whose papers rested on one damaged queen and a worker that can no longer be found — until it was tested directly, passed, and paid for the passing with its endemic status

The last page was about a name handed an island on loan. This one is about the name flagged in the same breath and handed nothing: Temnothorax lagrecai (Baroni Urbani, 1964). Laestrygon was promoted by a filing decision and still waits for its revision. Lagrecai was never promoted at all — and that turns out to be the luckier history, because when its test finally came, it came as specimens, not paperwork.

First, the name begins with almost nothing. Baroni Urbani described it in 1964, naming it for the Italian entomologist Marcello La Greca, from material collected by Giovanni Sichel in the Bosco di S. Pietro, on the Hyblaean Plateau in south-eastern Sicily. The type series, as the 2022 redescription summarises it, was an unspecified number of workers and a single queen — and the queen, the atypical caste to anchor a name on in a genus whose taxonomy is built mostly around workers, was made the holotype despite being damaged, missing both antennae.

Second, the worker it was described from cannot be produced. The worker caste’s description rested on one specimen its author called an ergatotype — a term that no longer carries standing under the zoological code, leaving the specimen a simple paratype in law. It has since been lost: glimpsed once, over twenty years before the redescription, in a collector’s home, and absent from every museum collection the revisers searched. Worse, the original description of that lost worker shows features that match none of the type or non-type workers since found — whether the specimen was truly odd or the description imprecise, no one can now say, because the evidence is gone.

Third, then silence. After 1964 almost nothing was published on the species; the 2022 authors note its name surfaced only a handful of times in nearly six decades. The 2021 Sicilian account counted it, like laestrygon, among the island’s endemics whose status appeared doubtful for lack of clearly defined diagnostic features. Two doubtful names, flagged together: one would be handed an island by a checklist, the other would simply keep waiting.

Fourth, the test came — and it was a real one. In 2022 Schifani, Prebus and Alicata redescribed lagrecai inside an integrative study combining morphology with phylogenomics, alongside three newly described species. They examined fifty-six colony samples from twenty-three localities — over two hundred workers, plus queens and males — together with the damaged holotype and surviving paratypes. The holotype, antennae or no, proved fully coherent with the queens collected alongside workers of the same form, and the revisers declared the question of the species’ identity resolved. The phylogeny placed it as sister to the newly described T. marae, the pair close to T. flavicornis. A doubtful name, given a diagnosis at last: pale and yellowish with concolorous antennal clubs, long worker propodeal spines, a weak or absent metanotal groove, fine areolate sculpture.

Fifth, keeping cost it its exclusivity. The redescribed species turned out to occur almost all over Sicily — and in the Maltese Islands besides, across a channel once bridged by land; some Maltese specimens long filed under another name proved on re-examination to be partly this one. So the 2022 checklist literature records the quiet demotion: lagrecai discovered to be subendemic, not endemic, because of Malta. It is a relatively thermophilous, soil-nesting, single-queen species, taken from near sea level to about 840 metres, in shrubland and open forest — wide enough in niche and range, the revisers suggest, to be in a comparatively comfortable conservation position. And in the 2025 list of seventeen Sicilian Temnothorax it stands unremarked, no caveat attached — the only one of the two doubtful names of 2021 that now needs none.

So the two names answer the same doubt in opposite currencies. Laestrygon gained a map before it was granted a settled name, and keeps both only on loan. Lagrecai gained a settled name and lost its claim to be Sicily’s alone. What a local name holds, when no filing decision ever promotes it, is exactly what it can survive being measured against: one damaged queen, one lost worker, fifty-eight years of silence — and then, when the specimens finally came, the truth that it was real, widespread, and not exclusively Sicilian at all.

A walk through an unpromoted keeping. Five stages: a name founded on one damaged queen in a single wood in 1964; the worker it was described from lost, its odd description unverifiable; nearly six decades of silence and a doubtful-endemic flag; a direct integrative test in 2022 that finds the holotype coherent and the identity resolved; and a keeping confirmed at the price of endemic status, the species found across Sicily and Malta. Schematic, compressed from the published accounts, with the lost specimen labelled as lost.

Walk it in order.

Schematic only: no colony is promised this exact history. Labelled cautions: do not present the lost ergatotype’s deviating features as the species’ real characters — the 2022 authors leave open whether they were the specimen’s or the description’s error. Do not call lagrecai a Sicilian endemic — it is subendemic since the Maltese records were recognised. Do not transfer laestrygon’s pending-revision caveat to lagrecai — its identity was tested and declared resolved in 2022, a different standing entirely. Do not open the kept piece, check first-cold.html before a day whose high was actually in the 50s, grade second-one.html, re-run the integrity walk, or re-grade Antares — earlier sittings closed those.