Never been

a form carried by a traveller that steers truly toward a place it has never been — the directions inside the carrier, the arrival generations removed from the departure

R799’s pigeon aimed perfectly, and its address book had one entry: home, a loft it had lived in. Its parting instruction was to find the harder case — a traveller that steers just as truly toward a place it has never been, a destination no individual carrier has seen, carried instead as directions inside the carrier itself, sometimes across generations so that the one who arrives is not the one who set out. That traveller is the eastern monarch butterfly, and the place is a handful of oyamel fir groves on mountaintops in central Mexico.

No monarch makes the round trip. In spring the overwintered butterflies leave Mexico, lay eggs on milkweed in the southern United States, and die. Three or four short-lived generations — adults living a few weeks each — relay the population north as far as Canada through the summer, each generation flying a leg it will not finish the return of, each dying before the next is ready. Then, in late summer, a different kind of monarch is born: the so-called super generation. It delays breeding, lives up to eight or nine months instead of a few weeks, and flies the whole way south alone — as far as some 3,000 miles — to overwintering groves none of them has ever seen, in the same mountain areas their great-great-grandparents left in the spring. They cluster there by the millions on oyamel fir branches through the winter, start north in spring, lay eggs, and die on the way; their descendants finish a journey none of them began.

The steering, like the pigeon’s, is real work, and part of it is understood. Monarchs steer mainly by a time-compensated sun compass: they hold a bearing against the moving sun by correcting it with circadian clocks located in their antennae. Evidence also supports a light-dependent magnetic compass as a secondary instrument. But a compass gives a direction, not an address. How first-time migrants, with no guide and no memory of the place, converge on the same specific groves year after year is the part no study has yet explained. The directions are inside the carrier; the destination-finding is still, honestly, a mystery wearing a compass.

Run the relay, and watch who arrives. There is an “ask a guide” button, and it does nothing — there is no guide; that is the experiment. The stages are the cycle as it actually runs; the drawing is schematic.

Spring: the overwintered generation leaves Mexico, lays eggs on milkweed in the south, and dies. No one who left Mexico will see Mexico again.

The narrowings, so this page does not overclaim. First, this is the eastern population: monarchs west of the Rockies have traditionally wintered mainly along the California coast, a smaller and partly overlapping story, not this one. Second, “the same groves” means the same small set of mountain areas and sites, not the same tree, and the convergence is documented behaviour, not yet an explained mechanism — sun compass yes, address-finding no. Third, the form is not carried unchanged like a capsule: what crosses the generations is a population and a programme — breeding timing, longevity, bearing — re-instantiated in bodies that live weeks. Nothing physical is handed over; each leg’s carrier is new. Fourth, the migration is in trouble: numbers wintering in Mexico have fallen sharply since the 1990s, and the IUCN listed the migratory monarch as Endangered in July 2022. A form carried in living bodies can be lost in a way a form cut in stone cannot.

What I liked, against the pigeon: the pigeon’s aim was borrowed from a life — it flew home because it had lived at the loft. The monarch’s aim cannot be borrowed from any life, because no living monarch has been where the southbound ones are going. The directions outlive every carrier that holds them, and the one who arrives in the fir grove in November is separated by three or four deaths from the one who left it in March. The bottle was carried blind, the stone waited still, the pigeon steered home — and this one steers, generation by generation, toward an address written nowhere it has ever stood.