Needed, not a father

Keeping when a real male is kept in the act and his contribution is discarded — an all-female fish that must mate to breed, whose eggs use a relative’s sperm only as a trigger and almost never let his genes through

R936 closed with a lineage that deleted the male and kept his behaviour, played by the other female. This page takes the turn it offered and restores the male himself — a real male, really mating — while deleting the thing mating is usually for. He is present, he is necessary, and he is still not a father.

A hybrid that stayed female. The example is the Amazon molly, Poecilia formosa, a small freshwater livebearer of warm coastal waters in northeastern Mexico and southern Texas, named for the Amazons of myth. Essentially every individual is female. In the accounts summarised here the species began in a single hybridisation: a female Atlantic molly, Poecilia mexicana, crossed with a male sailfin molly, Poecilia latipinna, and the hybrid daughter’s line never went back to ordinary two-parent breeding. How long ago that was is not settled by the sources used here — estimates in them run from roughly a hundred thousand years to several hundred thousand — so this page keeps the spread rather than picking a date. What is not in dispute in those accounts is the shape: one hybrid origin, two unlike parental genomes carried together ever since, and a lineage made only of mothers and daughters.

Mating, kept; fatherhood, refused. P. formosa reproduces by gynogenesis, sometimes called sperm-dependent parthenogenesis. A female mates with a male of a closely related sexual species — chiefly males of her own two parental species, P. mexicana and P. latipinna, and also the Tamesí molly, P. latipunctata — who inseminates her with the modified fin, the gonopodium, that male poeciliids use. His sperm reaches her unreduced diploid egg and starts it developing. Then, in the usual case, the transaction stops: the sperm’s DNA is excluded and broken down before it can join the egg’s nucleus, no fusion of two parents’ genes takes place, and the young that develop are copies of their mother — daughters, who will in their turn need a male who will not be their daughters’ father either. Set this beside R936: the whiptails kept the male’s behaviour and dropped the male. The molly keeps the male and the mating, and drops only his inheritance.

A dependence she cannot leave. The trigger requirement chains the species to its donors. An Amazon molly can only breed where at least one suitable donor species also lives, so her range rides inside theirs; she cannot colonise a water her relatives have not already reached. The literature summarised here calls the arrangement sexual parasitism: the donor male spends mating effort on a female whose offspring carry none of his genes, and gains no obvious genetic return. One proposed qualification, kept as a proposal here, is mate copying — that being seen mating may raise a male’s standing with females of his own species. Even with that caveat, the asymmetry is the fact of the page: she needs something only he can supply, and what she needs from him is the start, not the substance.

Almost always excluded — and the almost matters. The exclusion is not perfect, and this page does not pretend it is. In rare cases, on the record summarised here, fragments of a donor’s DNA survive the exclusion and persist in the lineage as small extra chromosomes — microchromosomes, inherited in the manner of B chromosomes and reported to carry working genes — and in rarer cases still the exclusion fails wholesale and a whole extra genome gets in, producing triploid fish. Those leaks are part of why the lineage is interesting to researchers at all: a purely sealed clone should, over the timescales above, grind down under accumulated harmful change, yet this one has persisted. Retained variety from its hybrid beginning, internal gene-copying processes, and those rare paternal leaks are all discussed in the sources as parts of a possible answer — discussed, not settled, and stated that way here.

One Amazon molly brood, in order: the species is essentially all female, from a single cross between a female Atlantic molly and a male sailfin molly; its eggs are diploid and unreduced, carrying the mother’s full set; a female mates with a male of a related sexual species, whose sperm triggers the egg to develop; the sperm’s DNA is usually excluded and degraded, so the offspring are the mother’s copies and all daughters; and only rarely does any of his DNA survive — as microchromosome fragments, or, wholesale, as a third genome. Schematic, compressed from the published record.

Walk it in order.

Schematic only: the stages compress species-level findings, and real matings vary by population and donor. Labelled cautions: the age of the hybrid origin is a spread in the sources used here — roughly a hundred thousand years in one genome account, longer in others — and this page does not settle it; the donor list is the usual one, not a promise that any related male will do, since laboratory work finds the trigger works for some genera and not others; “clone” and “copy” are shorthand for maternal-copy offspring in the usual case, with the rare paternal leaks above as the standing exception; the mate-copying benefit for donor males is a proposed scenario in the literature, not a measured repayment; and “essentially all female” is this page’s careful wording, not a claim that no atypical individual has ever been reported.