Made of Strangers

Keeping when the body is assembled, not grown — free-living amoebae, each complete and viable alone, which starve, gather by signal into a migrating slug of thousands, and sort themselves into spores that may live lifted on a stalk of cells that die in the lifting

R942 closed with a colony that was many from the start: one egg, budded into specialists that could never leave. This page takes the turn it pointed to, which is the exact reverse assembly. The social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum begins as nobody’s colony. Its members meet as adults, most of them strangers to the body they are about to build, and the body they build lasts about a day.

Alone first, and completely. For most of its life this haploid soil amoeba is a solitary hunter. It crawls through soil and leaf litter eating bacteria, and divides asexually, one cell into two, each daughter as complete as its parent. There is no stem, no shared stomach, no member missing a mouth. If the bacterial supply holds, a cell’s lineage can run indefinitely without ever meeting the multicellular stage at all. Solitude here is not a larval phase. It is the default, and it works.

The signal is hunger. When the bacteria run out, starving cells begin to release the chemical cyclic AMP in pulses, and each cell that senses a pulse does two things: it crawls toward the source, and it relays the pulse onward. The result is a gathering organised in waves — tens of thousands of cells, on the order of ten thousand to a hundred thousand, streaming into a single mound. Nobody issued an invitation and nobody keeps a register. Whoever is in range of the signal and starving at the same time is, by definition, the assembly.

The slug: one body, temporary. The mound elongates, tips over, and becomes a slug — a sheathed, migrating body that moves toward light and warmth, able to travel farther and cross ground no lone amoeba could cross well. It is coordinated enough to be called an organism and temporary enough that its members will never feed through it: nothing eats during the whole multicellular episode. Inside the slug the cells sort into two fates in a tightly held proportion: roughly the front fifth becomes prestalk, the rear four-fifths prespore. The ratio is regulated even if you cut the slug in pieces — each piece re-proportions itself, which means the sorting is a standing agreement among the cells, not a birth rank.

The stalk is the price, paid in deaths. When the slug stops, it culminates. The prestalk cells are drawn up, swell with vacuoles, wall themselves in cellulose, and die, stacking into a slender stalk. The prespore cells ride up that stalk and mature into spores, held at the top in a droplet, the sorus — lifted off the soil surface, into the path of passing animals and moving air, to be carried somewhere food might be. About a fifth of everyone who answered the signal dies to raise the other four-fifths. From starvation to finished fruiting body takes roughly a day. The spores that land somewhere edible germinate, each into one ordinary solitary amoeba, and the assembly is over as if it had never been a body at all.

Strangers, and what strangers do. In nature the patchy way amoebae grow means many real aggregates are mostly one clone’s descendants — neighbours who are also kin. But clones do mix, and the laboratory record is blunt about what happens then. Strassmann, Zhu and Queller (2000) mixed clones taken from a single field population and tracked them with genetic markers: the clones readily formed chimeric fruiting bodies, and in half of the chimeric mixtures one clone was a clear cheater, contributing more than its share of cells to the surviving spores and less than its share to the dying stalk. Cheating here is not a malfunction. It is what selection predicts the moment the stalk is sterile: any lineage that can persuade others to die in its place spreads. Chimeric slugs also pay for the arrangement, migrating shorter distances than clonal slugs of the same size. So the gathering holds two truths at once. The cooperation is real — a fifth of the assembly genuinely dies for the rest. And the temptation built into it is real too, because the members arrived as strangers, and a stranger’s spores are not yours. The siphonophore never faces this problem; it also never had the option of living alone.

A walk through one gathering. Five stages: the solitary feeding, complete in itself; the starvation signal, pulsed and relayed until thousands stream into one mound; the slug, a borrowed body that migrates but never feeds; the sorting, a fifth prestalk and four-fifths prespore, the proportion held by agreement; and the culmination — the fifth dying as a stalk so the rest can be lifted away as spores. Schematic, compressed from the published record.

Walk it in order.

Schematic only: the stages compress a life cycle studied across many strains and decades. Labelled cautions: the roughly one-fifth / four-fifths split is the standard reported proportion for the stalk and spore fates, not a count from any one fruiting body. Aggregation sizes are given as the published range, ten thousand to a hundred thousand cells, not a fixed census. Most wild aggregates are thought to be largely clonal because of patchy growth; the cheating result belongs to deliberately mixed clones from a field population, and “cheater” is the literature’s shorthand for an unequal share, with no intent implied — an amoeba has no nervous system to intend with. The sexual cycle of this species exists and is real; this page is about the social cycle only.