Lowest

One worker from Pazardzhik, kept in Crematogaster schmidti at 0.620 — the lowest winning score of the six type workers, held by a birthplace, a fellow syntype, and a colour sentence written in 1892

R1003 followed the syntype that stayed at 0.711 and ended on the one that scored lower still. This page follows that one alone. Everything below is summarised in my own words, with no quoted text beyond bare collecting and bibliographic data.

First, what the specimen is. It is a worker collected in August 1891 at Tatar Bazarnik — modern Pazardzhik, in Bulgaria — by A. Forel, a year before the name it carries was published, and it is now housed in Geneva under the identifier MHNG-ENTO-0296684. Its label, in paraphrase, names it as Forel’s variety of Crematogaster scutellaris — and spells that variety’s name christovichii, a spelling the revision itself flags with a [sic!]: the specimen carries a misspelling of its own name. In 1892 Forel published it as christowitchii, a variety of scutellaris; it was carried as a subspecies from 1893, and in 1922 Emery sank it as a junior synonym of schmidti, where it has rested for a century. It has one fellow syntype, a second Geneva worker, MHNG-ENTO-0296687, collected the same month at Sliven, elsewhere in Bulgaria.

Second, how it scored. Run as a wild card against the revision’s four clusters, the Pazardzhik worker came back at 0.620 for schmidti — and 0.379 for ariadnae, the new Cretan species, with 0.001 for graeca and less than 0.001 for ionia. Of the six type workers the revision tested, whose winning scores span 0.620 to 0.990, this is the lowest winner of all: nearly two chances in five that its own measurements belong to another species. Its fellow from Sliven scored 0.898 for schmidti, with 0.088 for ariadnae — the same runner-up, at a distance. The revision notes of both syntypes only that their scores for schmidti fell below 0.9 and that ariadnae stood second for each.

Third, what actually kept it. Not the number, and this time not even close. In the schmidti account the revisers say, in paraphrase, that the combination of the syntypes’ Bulgarian origin and the colour information in Forel’s original description — which described the animal, in his German, as red with a black abdomen — affirms that christowitchii belongs with schmidti. The runner-up is excluded the same way in the results passage: membership in ariadnae is ruled out on coloration and zoogeography. Zoogeography does heavy work here, and it is worth seeing why it can: the revision treats ariadnae as an endemic of Crete, an island species, and schmidti as its widespread Balkan sister — the discussion names the two as sister species, which is exactly why a Bulgarian schmidti-relative can sort measurably toward the Cretan one. But a worker pinned in inland Bulgaria in 1891 cannot be the Crete endemic without rewriting the map, and its describer’s own colour words match the red-bodied, dark-gastered pattern the revision gives schmidti. Birthplace, a three-word colour phrase from 1892, and a fellow syntype at 0.898: those are the witnesses. The measurement is the weakest of them, and it is printed anyway.

Fourth, what this type actually holds. Not a living name. Christowitchii has been a junior synonym since 1922, and the revision announces that its morphometric analyses confirm that synonymy — a striking sentence to set beside a 0.620. What the syntypes anchor is an attachment: the claim that this dead name belongs to schmidti and to nothing else. An attachment is not judged the way a membership is. Nobody asked the Pazardzhik worker to prove, from its own body alone, which species it is; the question put to the whole file was whether anything in it forces the name to move. The measurement leans, the birthplace forbids the lean’s destination, the describer’s sentence agrees with the birthplace, and the fellow syntype stands nearer the mark. Nothing forces the move. The name stays where Emery put it.

So is 0.620 a keeping, or only a postponement? A keeping — but a keeping of a different kind than the Smyrna worker’s. At 0.711 the witnesses agreed and the specimen stayed in a narrowed living name. At 0.620 the witnesses do not so much agree as divide the labour: the number reports a genuine resemblance to a sister species across the sea, and the other witnesses explain why that resemblance cannot be acted on. Nor does the worker stand alone in its weakness: a syntype series is a shared anchor, and the Sliven worker’s 0.898 is part of what the Pazardzhik worker holds with. The series, judged as a series, was never in doubt. What 0.620 marks is the point where a single body stops being able to carry its name by itself — and the file, honestly printed, carries it the rest of the way.

The walk — five moments in one worker’s working life, schematic only. Click each stage.

collected in Bulgaria, 1891
a syntype, under a misspelt name
sunk as a synonym, 1922
measured, at only 0.620
kept in schmidti, by the file

Pick a stage.

The excluded worker was certain and lost; the Smyrna worker was doubtful and consistent; this one was doubtful and divided, and stayed anyway — because a type does not always hold a name up. Sometimes it holds a name down, in the synonymy where it was put, and the holding is done by everything around the body that the body itself can no longer say.