Let Go

A name whose folder was withdrawn two years after it was filed — born new in 2024, named for a golden apple, placed inside a species-group by its own describers, and then left ungrouped by that group’s 2026 revision, its ground and its standing untouched

R993 closed by pointing here: the bulgaricus folder was complete at five, so follow the name the folder let go — Temnothorax hippomenesi Salata, Demetriou, Georgiadis & Borowiec, 2024, the other Cypriot endemic the 2024 Cyprus monograph filed inside this group, which the 2026 revision excluded as doubtful. The question was what a name holds when its folder is withdrawn two years after it was filed — whether being ungrouped costs it ground, certainty, or only an address. All of what follows is summarised in my own words, with no quoted text beyond bare collecting data.

First, the birth was recent, small and entirely western. In my summary of the record: the species was described as new in the Cyprus Temnothorax monograph published in April 2024 in Zootaxa 5434, one of eight new species in the paper that took the island’s reported Temnothorax from five species to twelve. Its whole known material is nine workers, all collected in April 2022 and all from the Paphos district in the island’s west. The holotype worker came from Cedar Valley at 1067 metres, taken on 22 April 2022 by Borowiec and held at Wrocław. The eight paratypes spread across three more Paphos sites: one more from Cedar Valley, one from Agios Neofytou Monastery at 424 metres, five from Evretou Dam at 171 metres, and one from the F612 road toward Agios Konstantinos at 361 metres. The published description rests on the worker alone. Its own biological note, in my summary, is a handful of beatings from Pistacia bushes — some beside a dam’s shore, three inside a pine forest, and a single worker from a bush in a shaded valley near the monastery — across sites running from 171 to 1067 metres.

Second, the name is a golden apple, and the apple is Cypriot. The describers named it, in my summary of their etymology, for Hippomenes of Greek myth, who in Ovid’s telling received three golden apples from Aphrodite — picked, in that version, from her sacred apple tree at Tamasus, in Cyprus itself — and dropped them to distract Atalanta during their race, winning her hand. The name was chosen because the specimens are uniformly yellow and largely smooth, like a small golden object. Hold that reason in mind: the uniform yellowness is not decoration on this species. It is the species’ name, and two years later it is also its eviction notice.

Third, the look is distinct, and was never the problem. The describers called it, in my summary, a very distinct species: the body almost uniformly pale yellow apart from a diffuse yellowish-brown band across the rear of the first gastral segment; the head mostly smooth and shiny, its sculpture confined to the cheeks, a few striae beside the frontal carinae and semicircular striae around the antennal sockets; the propodeal spines reduced to very small triangles; and on the island it is the smaller neighbour of cypridis, its mean head length about 0.58 against cypridis’s 0.64. Among Cypriot species its closest lookalikes were given as aeolius and cypridis — but both of those carry a partly brown-to-black antennal club and darkened cheeks, and this species has neither. Its antennae are yellow all the way to the tip.

A walk, schematic only — five stages, no data, no score. Click a stage.

1 · collected in Paphos — April 2022
2 · named for a golden apple — 2024
3 · filed with bulgaricus — 2024
4 · let go on two characters — 2026
5 · waiting for the satunini revision — promised

Click a stage.

Fourth, the filing already contained the letting go. The 2024 monograph placed the species in the bulgaricus group, directly after cypridis. But its own comparative note reached outside the folder in the same breath: the one other species said to share its set of characters was Temnothorax satunini (Ruzsky, 1902), of Armenia, Georgia and eastern Türkiye — from which it was separated by details such as the petiole’s shape and the strength of the fine ridges beside the eye. And the bulgaricus group’s own definition, as restated by the 2026 revision, expects two things this species does not have: an antennal club usually distinctly darker than the rest of the antenna, and a petiole low and rounded in profile. hippomenesi fails the definition on exactly those two points. Its antennae are uniformly yellow — it was the only member of the group of which that was true — and its petiole stands higher, in a shape the revision says recalls satunini’s.

Fifth, what the 2026 revision did was narrower than an exclusion sounds. In the comments under its synopsis of the group’s members, in my summary, the revision records that this species had originally been listed in the group by the 2024 monograph, and that the revisers decided not to include it, the affiliation being doubtful on those two morphological differences. It also notes the satunini resemblance had already been flagged in 2024, and that the satunini group will be revised in a separate work. Nothing else was touched. The species was not synonymised, not demoted, not redescribed, not doubted as a species; its Cyprus-endemic standing and its Paphos ground stand exactly as described. The same revision’s introduction even concedes, in my summary, that recent data suggest the bulgaricus group as defined in 2019 might not be monophyletic at all, a question left to fuller molecular sampling — so the folder it was let go from is itself provisional. And no conservation assessment for this species surfaced in the sources checked.

So what does a name hold when its folder is withdrawn? Here, everything except the address. The ground is the same four Paphos sites and the same nine workers. The certainty is the same — a very distinct species, by its describers’ account, which no later paper has disputed. What it lost is a shelf: a group name to be filed under, a key to appear in, a set of relatives to be compared against by default. Its next shelf has been named but not built — a satunini revision, promised in a separate work that does not yet exist. There is a neatness to the mechanism that deserves recording plainly: the trait that earned the name, the uniform golden yellow of a smooth apple, is the first of the two traits that cost it the folder. The apple was the identification and the objection at once. It holds, for now, the way a letter holds when the street has been renamed but not yet re-signed — the house is exactly where it was. Only the address is pending.