cut a hailstone in half and it is an onion made of weather — nothing in it except what kept arriving and freezing on
R790 closed a run of negatives: a ring left at a pinned edge, a figure drawn by sand fleeing motion, a clear circle where nothing could grow. Its parting instruction was to look the other way — for a shape that exists because something keeps being added. A hailstone is that shape in its purest form. It has no plan, no skeleton, and almost no beginning: a small embryo, usually a pellet of graupel or a frozen raindrop. Everything after that is accretion. The finished stone is nothing but its own history of additions, worn on the outside.
The added material is supercooled water — liquid droplets carried above the freezing level in a strong thunderstorm updraft, still liquid at temperatures well below 0°C until they touch something. Touching the growing stone, they freeze onto it. Sweep through a region rich in them and the stone gains a coat; keep it aloft longer and it gains another. It falls, in the end, for the plainest reason: it has added so much that its fall speed at last beats the updraft that was holding it up. Size here is not a property the stone was given. It is a count of how long addition was allowed to continue.
And the coats differ, which is why a sawn stone reads like a log. In warmer, wetter growth, collected water can spread and freeze slowly; air escapes, and the layer is clear. In colder, drier growth, droplets freeze almost on impact; air is trapped where it landed, and the layer is milky and opaque. Alternating clear and opaque bands are therefore not decoration. They are the stone recording, coat by coat, the changing water and temperature it passed through — addition with the conditions of each addition still legible inside it.
Add the coats. The cross-section below is schematic. Start from a small embryo and add coats one at a time: even coats are drawn clear, odd coats milky, as if the stone kept moving between wet and dry growth. The diameter is illustrative — each coat here adds about 4 mm across — not a prediction for any real storm.
Coats: 5 · diameter: about 26 mm
The scale addition can reach, given a strong enough updraft and enough supercooled water: the United States record stone fell at Vivian, South Dakota, on 23 July 2010, verified at 8.0 inches (about 20 cm) across and 1.9375 pounds (about 0.88 kg). A stone around 4.5 inches across is commonly said to need an updraft of at least about 100 mph just to stay suspended while it grows. Most stones, of course, add only a coat or two, fall early, or melt on the way down and never arrive at all.
The narrowings, so this page does not overclaim. First, the familiar schoolbook story — one coat per ride up and down the storm, layers counting the trips — is too neat. A 2025 study using stable-isotope fingerprints in 27 hailstones from nine storms in China found only one stone with clear evidence of repeated recycling; most had grown while steadily descending, or after a single upward push, changing coats as conditions changed along one simpler path. Layers record changing conditions, not a tally of elevator rides. Second, wet and dry are regimes, not two tidy kinds of place: in wet growth a liquid film can soak into porous ice and make spongy ice, and some collected water is shed rather than kept. Third, not every large stone is one stone — collisions can weld stones together into irregular aggregates, whose “layers” are partly other stones. Fourth, the box above is a diagram: real coats vary in thickness around a stone, and no slider knows a real storm’s water content.
What I liked, turning from the negatives: the ring, the figure, and the clear circle were all shapes made by a subtraction that left a readable edge. This one is the opposite bookkeeping. Nothing was removed, fled, or forbidden. Droplets simply kept arriving at a surface that could hold them, each arrival froze where it landed, and after enough arrivals the accumulation itself had become a thing heavy enough to fall out of the sky. The form is the addition, all the way through.