The holder

someone whose job is generation 0 — and what the job actually holds

The previous pages on this site followed things handed along until nobody could say how far they had travelled, because the distance from the start had stopped changing. That left a plain question: in an ordinary handed-along thing, is anyone still holding the start — and would they know that is the job they have?

For one ordinary thing, the answer is yes, and the holder has a title. In St. Vith, Belgium, the Puratos Sourdough Library — founded in 2013, and the only library of its kind — keeps sourdough starters in numbered jars in refrigerated cabinets. Its keeper, Karl De Smedt, is a sourdough librarian. Reported counts grow as he collects: 105 starters in 2018, 125 in 2020, 153 stored in-house by 2024, from dozens of countries. Nothing circulates. A starter is chosen for its renown, its unusual origin, and often its claimed age, and the stated aim is to keep it in a state close to how it arrived.

Here is how a living original is held, in practice. Every two months each starter comes out of the fridge and is fed — refreshed with water and with its own flour of origin, which the original bakers supply in yearly quantities for exactly this purpose. Every new arrival is analysed in a laboratory, its microbes recorded. And strains isolated from the starters are also frozen at −80 °C.

Notice that those are two opposite methods, and the library uses both. Freezing holds the thing by stopping it: no feedings, no generations, the strains as they were. Feeding holds it by continuing it — and continuing is replacement. A refresh keeps only a portion of the old starter and builds the rest from fresh flour and water, so the share of the original material falls by that portion's fraction at every feeding:

Feed the jar. Pick how much of the old starter each refresh keeps, then press Feed. The counter is the share of the original material left. This page does not know the library's actual refresh ratio — this is the arithmetic of any feeding, at any ratio:

feedings: 0 · keeping: half each time · original material left: 100%

However gentle the keeping, the exponent wins. At the library's every-two-months rhythm a starter held since 2013 has been fed roughly 78 times — and the librarian knows this better than anyone: asked about a starter's claimed age, he says in effect that there is no test for it; how a starter is fed can change its microbial colonies, sometimes entirely, so a claim of great age has to be believed rather than verified. A controlled study makes his caution concrete from the other side: starters kept in one place and fed daily for just 14 days began fairly alike and diverged substantially, each flour fostering its own distinct bacterial community — which is presumably why the library insists on the flour of origin. The feeding is not what betrays the original. The feeding is also the only thing keeping it alive. Both, at once, in the same spoonful.

So what does the holder actually hold? Not the original microbes in the jar — those are a chain, continuous and plausible and, by his own account, possibly replaced wholesale along the way. He holds the things around the chain: the jar and its number, the name and the story of where it came from, the right flour arriving every year, the feeding rhythm, the laboratory record of what was in it when it arrived, and, in the freezer, strains stopped mid-chain before they could hand themselves on. Generation 0, where it survives at all, survives as a record and a practice — not as the living stuff.

And the holders who never got a library? Every bakery and kitchen that kept a starter alive for a century was doing this job without the title — feeding the yardstick, in the act of using it, never once in a position to compare the jar against its beginning. The librarian's distinction is not that he can do what they couldn't. It is that he knows the job is holding, says so, and keeps the record and the freezer alongside the jar, because the jar alone was never going to be enough.

Sources: Atlas Obscura's visit to the library (2018, updated 2025) for the founding, the collecting, and the feeding protocol; Smithsonian Magazine (2020) for the count at that date and the two-month feeding; Puratos's Sourdough Institute announcement (2024) for the 153 starters; McKenney and colleagues' flour study (PeerJ, reported by NC State) for the 14-day divergence.

← The Roamers