Fought in the Open

Keeping with no quiet option — a slave-maker recognised as an enemy the moment it arrives, whose raids are fought rather than slept through, and whose habit of killing the colony it robs may be why it stays rare

R957 closed with a raider that was never perceived: Temnothorax pilagens, whose muted cuticle chemistry kept its hosts from classing it as foreign at all. This page takes the turn it pointed to, to the close congener that gets no such quiet. Temnothorax duloticus was described by Wesson in 1937, from Ohio, and spent decades under the older genus name Leptothorax. It is one of three North American slave-making species in the Temnothorax group, and by every account the seldom-found one: the Ohio checklist calls it rarely collected, from a handful of scattered sites in that state, and older faunal accounts add Michigan and treat a reported Illinois record as unsubstantiated. Its hosts, in Ohio, are the same three relatives its congeners use — T. ambiguus, T. curvispinosus and T. longispinosus — but comparative work gives it a clear favourite: it attacks T. longispinosus only occasionally and prefers T. curvispinosus.

First, it is not its quiet cousin, and you can tell them apart on the body. The 2014 species description that named pilagens was built as a contrast with duloticus, and the differences are consistent: a longer antennal scape, a longer and less hump-backed mesosoma, a petiole whose rear slope carries a distinct step, fuller mandibular teeth where pilagens has mostly a wavy remnant, and longer, thinner propodeal spines. Same size class, same dulotic trade, different build — the two are close kin, not the same ant twice.

Second, the weapon is shared; the reception is not. That same description says the raids of pilagens resemble duloticus more than they resemble Protomognathus americanus, above all in the frequent, effective use of the sting in fights — aimed stings, paralysis, quick death, helped by strong flexor muscles that let the gaster bend. So the fencing sting is the family tool. What pilagens adds on top of it is the suppressed recognition that often keeps the tool in its sheath. Duloticus has no such addition in the accounts: its hosts meet it as an enemy, the raid is a fight from the start, and the sting is the method, not the fallback.

Third, its raids do not leave a colony behind to rob again. A later comparative survey of the three slave-makers puts the contrast in one move: where pilagens varies — sometimes lethal, sometimes seemingly peaceful, sometimes even taking adults home alive — duloticus is the fierce one, in most cases stinging its opponents to death first and taking the brood afterwards, with the local disappearance of the host colony as the result. Hare’s corral work, reported at the time, tells the same story at the scale of a victim’s acorn: adults killed, much of the brood eaten rather than carried, the emptied nest itself taken over. There is no raided-nest-survives-as-ideal here. The keeping is total, and terminal for the kept.

Fourth, the cost has been measured, and it lands on the raider’s own future. Hare and Alloway tested the assumption that slave-making actually costs the enslaved anything, setting host colonies in outdoor enclosures with no slave-maker, with P. americanus, or with duloticus. The prudent parasite left no significant mark: longispinosus colonies living alongside americanus matched the unparasitised controls on every demographic measure they took. The despotic one — their word for duloticus in the paper’s title — did the opposite: curvispinosus colonies exposed to it ended the season significantly down in queens, workers and larvae alike. A reported season-long version of the comparison put the raided hosts at roughly a third of the strength of unharassed colonies. The authors link that difference in conduct to a difference in fortune: a parasite that eradicates its hosts locally burns its own supply, which may be exactly why americanus is the common one in nature and duloticus the handful-of-sites rarity. Open fighting wins the acorn. It loses the neighbourhood.

Last, keeping here has the opposite direction to R957’s. The pillage ant’s problem was regulation by others: what limits a raider that loses nothing? This ant’s limit is built into its method. A marked-slave study makes the same point from inside the nest: lethal raiders that kill large numbers of the target colony’s workers leave their captives with, often, no living home colony anywhere nearby to return to — which is why the authors predicted such raiders would never need the slave-marking trick the gentler americanus evolved. Annihilation simplifies custody. It also ends it: every raid spends the very population the next raid needs, so the brood is kept the way a fire keeps a field.

A walk from the door to the empty acorn. Five stages: recognised at the door; the fight joined; opponents stung before brood is touched; brood taken and the colony gone; and the winner surveying a neighbourhood with one fewer colony in it. Schematic, compressed from the published accounts.

Walk it in order.

Schematic only: the stages compress a species description, comparative raid accounts and enclosure experiments, so no single raid is promised this exact sequence. Labelled cautions: do not hand duloticus the pillage ant’s camouflage — no account read for this page credits it with neutralising recognition chemistry, and its whole contrast with pilagens is that its hosts recognise and resist it. Do not invent attacker-casualty counts for it: R957’s closing line said its hosts inflict casualties on the attackers, and fighting is well attested, but the accounts summarised here quantify the host side of the ledger — deaths, lost queens and larvae, colonies gone — and give no raider-loss figure, so this page claims a fought, costly raid, not a numbered toll on both sides. Do not move the roughly-one-third figure off its ground: it is a reported season-long corral result, not a universal raid outcome. Do not give it any host but the three named, or drop the preference — curvispinosus is the favourite, longispinosus the occasional. Do not extend its range past Ohio and Michigan on the strength of the dismissed Illinois report. And do not call its destructiveness a proven sole cause of its rarity — the despotism-to- scarcity link is the authors’ argued reading of their experiment, not a closed mechanism.