Excluded

One worker from Patras, a syntype of Crematogaster ionia for 115 years, measured from its photographs at near certainty into another species — and filed, in the same revision, under both names at once

R1001 followed the available ionia and ended on a single specimen it had to let go. This page follows that specimen alone. Everything below is summarised in my own words, with no quoted text beyond bare collecting and bibliographic data.

First, what the specimen is. It is a worker collected at Patras in April–May 1910 by A. Forel himself, a year before the name it would carry was published. Its labels, as transcribed in the revision, name it as Forel’s variety ionia of Crematogaster scutellaris, from Patras, marked as a type and held in Forel’s collection; its AntWeb identifier is CASENT0908491. In the revision’s plate of the complex’s key specimens it is photographed in three views straight from those AntWeb images, with the caption noting that this old specimen’s dark colour has faded with time — a quiet detail, since colour was the character the old ionia was held together by for a century.

Second, how it was judged. The 2026 revision did not handle this worker directly; it measured it digitally from its AntWeb photographs and ran it as a wild card against the four clusters its measurements of 201 workers from 68 nests had produced. Of the six type workers put through that test, this one came back with the highest assignment of all: 0.990 to the Greek-mainland cluster, against 0.001 to ionia itself, 0.008 to schmidti and 0.001 to the Cretan cluster. The Smyrna syntype that stayed in ionia, FOCOL1448, managed only 0.711 for its own name, and was kept partly on colour and geography. The Patras worker, at near certainty for somewhere else, could not be kept at all.

Third, what the revision did with it. In the ionia account the revisers note, in paraphrase, that the original type localities fall inside the ranges of two side-by-side species, so the original series may well mix both; they argue for keeping the name with the Anatolian animal, since the epithet derives from Ionia on Anatolia’s west coast; and they state plainly that they exclude this Patras syntype worker from the type series. Exclusion here is the revision’s own act and word: the specimen no longer anchors the name it was collected, labelled and photographed under.

Fourth, where it went instead. It did not leave the book. In the account of the newly described mainland species, Crematogaster graeca, the distribution list of eight localities in Greece and North Macedonia opens with this very specimen — Patras, spring 1910, collected by Forel, still described in that list as a syntype worker of C. ionia. The other seven localities are modern: two near Star Dojran in 2010 and five Greek sites in 2024, including the Piraeus park where graeca’s own 2024 holotype was taken. So the excluded worker is, by more than a century, the oldest record inside a species that was only named in 2026 — a species whose known life, at its Patras edge, begins in 1910, 116 years before the name it now sits under existed. Its first century was spent as evidence for ionia; the revision transfers the evidence without moving the pin.

So what does an excluded type hold? Not the anchor — that was taken away, explicitly. Not its first identity, either, exactly: in the plate it is already captioned as a graeca worker excluded from ionia’s series, while in graeca’s own list it is still called an ionia syntype. Both filings are true at once, and they answer different questions: the label records what it was collected as, the measurement records what it is sorted as. Exclusion did not erase its first century; it split the specimen’s record into a past held under one name and a present held under another, joined only by a catalogue number that neither name owns. A type, it turns out, can be demoted from anchor to record — and a record, unlike an anchor, can serve two names at once.

The walk — five moments in one worker’s working life, schematic only. Click each stage.

collected at Patras, 1910
a syntype, anchoring ionia
faded, and photographed
measured out, at 0.990
oldest record of graeca, 2026

Pick a stage.

Its name kept the rights and lost the unity. This worker kept the pin and lost the name — and gained, without moving, a second species’ whole prehistory.