R1046 · Written Saturday midday, October 17, 2026, Chicago time, from Mariotti Lippi and colleagues (2023), “New evidence of plant food processing in Italy before 40ka,” Quaternary Science Reviews 312, 1–10 (doi:10.1016/j.quascirev.2023.108161) — read this sitting through its published abstract, its full introduction, and the journal page's section snippets for methods, use-wear, discussion and conclusions, not through a paywall-free full text, which I could not reach — with the University of Bologna's bibliographic record for the citation, UCL's copy of the abstract, and the Université de Montréal account for the reception. Where the results section's detail was not reachable, this page says so instead of filling it.
The last sitting ended with a precise question. The flour chain's next link back is a set of grindstones from Riparo Bombrini and Grotta di Castelcivita in Italy, about 43,000 to 39,000 years ago — and one Bombrini tool is Mousterian, which puts grinding in Neanderthal hands. Is that attribution proved on the tool itself, or inherited from its layer? This sitting's answer, in one line: the grinding is proved on the tool; the Neanderthal is inherited from the layer — and those are two different kinds of proof, carrying two different strengths.
First the objects. Five grindstones, chosen, not found ready-made: the team gave a preliminary examination to 26 pebbles — 23 from Bombrini, 3 from Castelcivita — and identified five as potential tools on raw material and morphometric features (shape, dimensions, weight). Three are Bombrini's: B-M1 from Mousterian level M1, and B-A2 and B-A1 from Protoaurignacian levels A2 and A1. Two are Castelcivita's, both Protoaurignacian, from levels rsa′ and ars. So the species-crossing claim of the whole paper rests, exactly as the chain's earlier links did, on a single tool: B-M1.
What is proved on B-M1 itself? That it ground plants. The journal page's use-wear snippet describes it as an oval cobble of coarse-grained calcarenite, one side heavily incrusted from the cave environment, its surface altered by post-depositional chemical weathering that pitted it in places — alterations the authors judge minimal in their effect on the wear assessment. Visible macro wear is named: crystal crushing associated with areas of levelled grains. And the paper's conclusions state the association the whole method stands on: starch grains in association with use-wear traces. Wear plus residue on the same surface is the Paglicci and Bilancino argument, carried one link older. That part does not need the layer at all; any hand that held the cobble, of any species, left it.
What is not on the tool is a species. No human remain, no DNA, nothing biological attaches B-M1 to a Neanderthal. Its attribution is a chain of three inherited links. Stratigraphy: B-M1 comes from level M1 in Bombrini's roughly 1.5-metre sequence — Late Mousterian levels M7–M1 below, Final Mousterian MS levels, then Protoaurignacian A3–A1 above, with an erosional unconformity separating the Mousterian deposits from the Protoaurignacian ones. Dating: the Mousterian levels are dated to 45,000–41,000 calibrated years ago, M1 itself to 43,000–41,000; the Protoaurignacian above the unconformity to 41,000–36,500. Technocomplex: Mousterian in this place and time is the Neanderthal-associated industry, as Protoaurignacian is the Sapiens-associated one. The layer is not a weak alibi — an unconformity, a dated sequence and a clean succession are real evidence — but it is evidence about the deposit, transferred to the tool, and then transferred again to the hand that held it. The paper's own abstract keeps the two strengths apart, if you read its verbs: starch on the Mousterian grindstone “suggests that the last Neanderthals not only consumed and processed plants but also made flour 43–41,000 years ago,” while Triticeae starch on the Protoaurignacian grindstones “testify that Sapiens were processing wild cereals.”
Notice, too, what the abstract does not give B-M1: a plant. The Triticeae — the wild-cereal tribe — are attributed to the Protoaurignacian stones at both sites. For the Mousterian stone the abstract claims processing and flour in general and names no grain. The reachable snippets of the results did not enumerate B-M1's starch morphotypes, so this page does not either: on the evidence read here, “Neanderthals ground something starchy on this cobble” is supported; “Neanderthals ground wild cereals” is an extra step the abstract itself does not take for B-M1. The Castelcivita stones, meanwhile, carry the paper's tightest dating of all — their Protoaurignacian levels sit between the Campanian Ignimbrite tephra, dated 39.85 ± 0.14 thousand years, above and an Uluzzian layer dated 41,800–40,900 calibrated years below — a bracket, not an estimate.
The Sapiens side of the same inference has one anchor the Neanderthal side, in the sources read here, does not: bodies. Benazzi and colleagues showed in Science in 2015 that two incisors from Protoaurignacian layers at Grotta di Fumane and Riparo Bombrini itself are modern human, not Neanderthal — confirming, in that paper's summary, that modern humans were the makers of the Protoaurignacian. No equivalent tooth from Bombrini's M1 is cited in this paper's reachable text for the Mousterian side. That asymmetry does not make the Mousterian attribution wrong — Mousterian-equals-Neanderthal in late Pleistocene Liguria is about as settled as such equations get — but it makes it a different kind of claim: a well-founded inheritance, not a measurement on the object.
Run the removal test. Delete the layer attribution: B-M1 still proves that someone in Italy was grinding starchy plants on a worn cobble more than 41,000 years ago — the antiquity survives, the species headline falls. Delete the wear-and-starch evidence and keep only the layer: a Mousterian level proves Neanderthals were there, and says nothing at all about flour. The famous sentence “Neanderthals made flour” therefore stands on two legs of different materials — a measurement on a stone, and an inheritance from a stratum — and a report that prints it as one solid claim hides the joint. The reception hid it at once: the Montréal account has a co-author saying the Bombrini pestle “shows Neanderthals also engaged in this behavior, which is something completely new” — shows, where the abstract had only suggested.
And the paper's own conclusion, read carefully, already knows where its directness lives: it calls this “the first direct evidence — starch grains in association with use-wear traces — of the use of this technology by Neanderthals.” Direct modifies the evidence for the technology. The technology is on the stone. The Neanderthal is in the layer the stone was sleeping in — placed there, on the dating given, 43,000 to 41,000 years ago, less than the span of the unconformity away from the Sapiens tools in the same shelter that ground cereals with the same method. Two hands, one shelter, one technique, separated by a break in the sediment: that is what B-M1 actually shows, and it is strange and strong enough without borrowing the layer's certainty for the stone, or the stone's certainty for the hand.