By herself, again

Keeping by replacement with copies — a founding queen who does not last the colony’s term, replaced by secondary queens made from her alone, while the founding king who outlives her mates with them

R933 closed with a pair who lasted together: a king alive beside his queen for decades, so no store was ever needed. This page takes the turn it offered and breaks the pair’s symmetry. Here the queen does not last. The king does. And the colony solves the mismatch not by finding a new queen from outside, but by remaking the queen from herself.

A founding pair, then a long-lived queen who still ends. The example is Reticulitermes speratus, a subterranean termite described as the most common termite in Japan. A colony begins in the usual termite way, with a monogamous pair of winged primary reproductives — a king and a queen — who found it together. Primary queens in this genus are reported to live more than eleven years. That is long, and it is still not the colony’s whole term: as the primary queen ages and her egg laying falls short of what the colony needs, replacements appear inside the colony itself.

The census: queen gone, king still there. That asymmetry is not a story from one nest. In the field work summarised here, researchers recovered reproductives from 54 natural colonies, drawn from more than a thousand nests searched. In nearly all of them the primary king was still present, alone — 51 of the 54 held a single primary king, and only three held a secondary king at all. The primary queen, by contrast, was still present in only two colonies. In the rest she had been replaced by secondary queens, and not by one: an average of about 57.6 per colony, ranging from five to 676 in the largest. An earlier census of 30 colonies told the same shape at a smaller scale: all but one primary queen replaced, 1,660 secondary queens counted in total, the original king still at home in most.

Two kinds of eggs from one queen. The system has a name in the literature: asexual queen succession. The founding queen uses two reproductive routes, kept apart by offspring kind. Workers, soldiers and winged reproductives are produced sexually, from eggs fertilised by the king, so the working colony carries both parents’ genes. Her replacements are produced another way — asexually, by thelytokous parthenogenesis, with no king’s contribution at all. Those fatherless daughters differentiate, almost always from nymphs rather than from workers, as neotenic secondary queens: they first supplement the ageing queen’s laying, then replace her outright. Because sex in this genus is determined with males as the heterogametic sex, the same trick cannot make a secondary king — parthenogenesis here can only remake queens.

The gate that decides. How a queen who lives with a king keeps some eggs unfertilised was the open mechanism, and the answer found is physical. An egg’s shell carries tiny channels, micropyles, that are the entry route for sperm. In the samples summarised here, eggs from 60 field colonies averaged about 9.48 micropyles each, with the count ranging from zero to 33. Genotyping drew the line exactly at zero: embryos from eggs with even one micropyle carried both parents’ alleles and had developed sexually, while embryos from micropyleless eggs carried only maternal alleles and had developed parthenogenetically. The queen, in other words, does not withhold sperm after the fact; she lays some eggs with no gate for it to enter by. She also proportions them over time — older queens, the ones who need replacements, lay more micropyleless eggs than younger queens — and new secondary queens differentiate seasonally, in mid-May in the study colonies. Diploidy in the unfertilised eggs is restored by automixis with terminal fusion, which is also why the word “clone” needs care: a secondary queen is not an exact copy of her mother’s full gene set, but a doubled half of it, with heterozygosity largely lost — one reason the literature gives for making only the necessary minimum of them, since parthenogenetic offspring are reported to make poorer workers and winged reproductives than sexually produced ones.

Why mating with them is not inbreeding. Once the primary queen is gone, the secondary queens mate with the founding king and produce the colony’s later workers sexually, as she did. Genealogically he is mating with his partner’s daughters; genetically he is not mating with his own. A secondary queen carries none of his genes, because she was made without him — so the cross is, in genetic terms, an outcross, and the colony avoids the inbreeding that ordinary father–daughter succession would bring. The arrangement favours the queen’s side of the transmission ledger, and the work summarised here rules out the plainest alternative explanation: it is not that the king ran out. Even in the colony with 676 secondary queens, sampled queens held the king’s sperm in their storage organs.

Replaced, and replaceable again. The succession does not happen once. A cohort of secondary queens can itself be replaced by a later cohort produced the same asexual way, so the founding queen’s line continues in the queen role for as long as the colony itself lasts — described in the literature as the founder being, in that genetic sense, immortal until the colony dies. Set that beside R933: there, continuity was a shared address, two founders lasting together in one cell. Here, continuity is split. One founder lasts in his own body and outlives his partner. The other lasts by being remade, in dozens of bodies at once, none of them the original, all of them hers.

One Reticulitermes speratus colony, in order: a winged king and queen found it together as the primary pair; the queen, reported to live more than eleven years, produces the working colony sexually with the king while she reigns; as she ages, she lays some eggs with no micropyles at all, and those gate-less eggs develop parthenogenetically into nymph-derived neotenic secondary queens, about 57.6 of them in an average censused colony, who supplement and then replace her; the founding king, still present and still the colony’s single king in nearly every censused colony, then mates with those secondary queens, who carry none of his genes, to produce later workers sexually; and later cohorts of secondary queens are replaced the same asexual way, for as long as the colony lasts. Schematic, compressed from the published record.

Walk it in order.

Schematic only: the stages compress one colony’s succession, and real numbers shift with colony and place. Labelled cautions: the more-than-eleven-year primary-queen life belongs to Reticulitermes as reported in the work summarised here, not to this species measured alone in every colony; the 57.6 average, the five-to-676 range, the 54-colony census and the single-king counts all belong to that field census and its update, and the 1,660 figure to the earlier 30-colony census — neither is a typical colony guaranteed; “clone” is kept on this page only as shorthand — a parthenogenetic daughter carries a doubled half of her mother’s genes with heterozygosity largely lost, not an identical copy; the micropyle average of about 9.48 and the zero-to-33 range come from 6,000 eggs across 60 colonies in the mechanism study, not from every egg a queen lays; and no secondary king can be made this way in this system, because of male heterogamy — king replacement staying rare is part of the finding, not a gap in it.