Perenotus read whole — the bug’s Canarian cousins, on an island model: a mirid genus with no sexual dimorphism at all, in which males and females alike are ant-shaped and short-winged, copying only the reddish half of a two-coloured endemic
R1017 closed its page by pointing across the water and asking whether the female-only, wing-paid bargain of Mimocoris rugicollis is a mirid pattern or a coincidence repeated. Read whole, the Canarian case answers that question by refusing its terms. In the tribe these bugs belong to, the sex-split is the rule the identification keys are built on — females short-winged or ant-shaped, males always fully winged. The genus Perenotus is diagnosed, in so many words, by breaking it: no sexual dimorphism, male and female both myrmecomorphic, both micropterous. Here the disguise is not held by half the species. Both sexes pay. Everything below is summarised in my own words, with no quoted text beyond bare collecting and bibliographic data.
First, a whole system shrunk to an archipelago. The Mediterranean system of the last three pages — Camponotus lateralis and its Crematogaster scutellaris-group models — spans, on this paper’s figure, more than a million square kilometres. The Canarian analogue spans about 3,300. The archipelago itself is seven main volcanic islands, some 90 km off the northwest African coast, 7,492 km² in all, with 7,820 invertebrate species (45% endemic) and 61 ant species (31% endemic). Every member of the proposed system is endemic to it. The model, Crematogaster alluaudi Emery, 1893, occurs only on the four western islands — El Hierro, La Palma, La Gomera and Tenerife. It is territorial and aggressive; an alerted worker folds its gaster up over its back, scorpion-like, and like other Crematogaster it secretes a Dufour’s-gland venom when disturbed. It was found at 99 localities, 524 workers, from 19 m to 2,378 m. And it comes in two colours that never mix in this study: the head is always reddish and the gaster blackish, while the mesosoma is either wholly reddish or wholly blackish — no intermediates, and no colony holding both. The reddish form occurs on all four islands; the blackish form only on the northern slope of Tenerife, where it has carried a subspecies name, Cr. alluaudi noualhieri Emery, 1893, whose sole distinct difference is that colour and whose status the authors call taxonomically doubtful, treating it here simply as a morph.
Second, the ant follower, graded perfectly. Camponotus guanchus Santschi, 1908 — described from northern Tenerife, its holotype a blackish-mesosoma worker — was known from El Hierro, La Palma and Tenerife, and this paper adds La Gomera. It lives inside the model’s country in every sense the paper can test: found only within alluaudi’s area, at 30 localities and 70 workers, in a narrower altitudinal band (35–686 m) and mostly in the same thermo-sclerophyllous woodland. At the 16 localities where the two occurred together, the mesosoma colours matched every time — eight reddish with reddish, eight blackish with blackish, none crossed — a pattern the authors put at p = .0001 against chance. In syntopy the follower never exceeded a tenth of the model’s workers. It follows the model’s trails, was seen sharing weakly used mixed trails to Euphorbia lamarckii flowers, and escapes when it meets a Crematogaster worker, which in turn behaves aggressively toward it. There is exactly one exception in the whole dataset: a single reddish guanchus worker inside the blackish zone, found in an anthropised vegetal-waste deposit, which the authors suggest may have been introduced there. The resemblance itself is old news at half strength — Emery in 1893 and Santschi in 1919 had already noticed a similarity to alluaudi, but they knew only the blackish morphs.
Third, the bugs — one species that was two islands. Perenotus was erected by Roca-Cusachs & Goula in 2016, its name built from Pere — for the entomologist P. Oromí, honoured for his work on Macaronesian insects — and the Latin notus, known; its type species is the new one, P. malobae. The genus exists because an earlier name turned out to hold two islands at once: Systellonotus stysi Ribes, Pagola-Carte & Heiss, 2008 had been described from females collected on both Tenerife and La Palma, and careful re-examination showed the island specimens belong to different species. So stysi stayed with Tenerife, as Perenotus stysi — its female redescribed, its male described for the first time — and the La Palma animal became P. malobae. On the labels and in the authors’ field notes the genus prefers dry lowlands with Euphorbia balsamifera and Euphorbia canariensis associations, where ground-dwelling animals commonly shelter under stones against heat and predators. Its diagnosis is where this page turns: general colouring reddish brown, a long rostrum reaching the base of the abdomen, a triangular scutellum with a distinctive conical hump on its rear half, and short hemelytra lacking a membrane, with a longitudinal pale stripe along the outer margin and no transverse stripes — and, stated flatly among the diagnostic characters, no sexual dimorphism: male and female myrmecomorphic, micropterous.
Fourth, what that refusal costs, and what it copies. The 2016 paper sets Perenotus against its relatives explicitly. In the genera it keys to alongside — Alloeomimus, Systellonotus, part of Hallodapus — the females are short-winged or ant-shaped while the males are always fully winged; in the other hump-scutellum genera named, and in the African genera it keys toward (Skukuza, Aspidacanthus, Myombea), the male is likewise macropterous. That is the background pattern R1017’s opening asked about, and it is real — in this tribe the wing-paid disguise is ordinarily the female’s alone, exactly as in Mimocoris. Perenotus is the exception that defines a genus: the male gave up the flight the tribe’s males keep, and wears the ant’s outline too. And the copy itself is narrower than the ant follower’s. Both Perenotus species have a reddish head, a reddish thorax and a blackish abdomen, so they mimic only those alluaudi workers with a reddish mesosoma — the authors predicted the bugs would occur only where that morph does, and so far they do: ten known localities on Tenerife and La Palma in all, every individual sharing the reddish model’s distribution and pattern, and no Perenotus record at all from the blackish north of Tenerife. One individual of P. malobae was found inside a nest of Cr. alluaudi, which the authors take as underpinning the hypothesis. The bugs’ records were too few to test statistically — the paper says so plainly — whereas the ant follower’s sixteen-for-sixteen match could be. Earlier authors had already called both species myrmecomorphic, but before 2024 no model ant genus had been suggested for them at all.
Fifth, the predator is a presumption here. The paper argues the whole system is Batesian — the followers comparatively defenceless, the model unpalatable and aggressive, the disguise an antipredator adaptation — from minority frequency, an embedded distribution, trail-following and the model’s aggression. Its candidate driver is the endemic lizard genus Gallotia: five taxa share the ants’ islands, ants turn up in a quarter to nearly half of studied Gallotia galloti droppings and make up 30–74% of the insects eaten, and maximal densities on Tenerife are estimated at 1,300–3,300 lizards per hectare, a density compensation the authors argue could make a handful of predator species pressure enough. But the conclusion is stated as an interpretation with its hinge showing: it presumes the lizards avoid alluaudi. For this island model, in this paper, that avoidance is not demonstrated — a contrast with the ant follower of R1015, whose continental system at least has lizard-ingestion comparisons behind it. The island copy is in one way better graded than any before it — a perfect sixteen-for-sixteen colour match, tested — and in another way worse: its bugs are untested for scarcity, and the predator the whole reading leans on has not yet been shown to refuse the model.
A five-stage walk (schematic only — the stages are this page’s arrangement, not a scheme from any paper):
Pick a stage.
The model on the continent held a coast. This one holds four western islands and two colours, and never lets them meet inside a colony. Its ant follower holds the copying as a perfect local match — whichever colour the place wears, it wears. Its bugs hold it as a single colour only, in ten known places, at a price the rest of their tribe charges only to females: both sexes grounded, both sexes in the disguise, a whole genus defined by a dimorphism that is not there.