Barely an Elder

The elder the last newborn was measured against — a Greek ant named for the chief town of Lesvos, who turns out to be barely two years older than the newborn, born wide across four islands and a mainland shore, after a first life under a name in quotation marks

The last page ended with an elder: Temnothorax mytilenes, the species the newborn sappho is told from by yellow femora and short triangular spines, an elder whose name points at Mytilene, the chief town of Lesvos. This page went to look at the elder — and found that the seniority is mostly an illusion of the filing. Ask what an elder holds when it is barely older than the newborn measured against it.

First, the elder is a newborn too. Mytilenes was described in 2023, by Salata, Środoń and Borowiec, in the taxonomic revision of the graecus species-group from Greece (Annales Zoologici 73: 51–68). It was one of two species that revision brought into the world — the other was phaetoni, endemic to the Cyclades. The true elders of the group are the three names of 1911, aeolius, graecus and smyrnensis, and the revision’s work on them was anchoring: fresh diagnoses and redescriptions, and a lectotype designated for each, fixing each old name to a single specimen. Mytilenes was not among the anchored. It was among the launched. When sappho arrived in 2025 and was told from it, the “elder” it leaned on had held its own name for two years.

Second, it was born wide. The mainland newborn of this sequence, nebulosus, began as two separated points, and the island twin, sappho, as two islands. Mytilenes began as five places at once: in Greece, Lesbos, Samos, Kos and Rhodes, and across the water in Türkiye, the Ayvalık Peninsula — four islands and a mainland shore, held under one name from its first day. Nobody had to ask whether its points were truly one; the description simply asserted the span, the way a name does when the sorting happens all at once, in a single revision, with all the specimens on one table. Its ground, in other words, was never walked into gradually. It was declared.

Third, it had a first life under a name in quotation marks. A later survey of the ants of Lesvos records mytilenes from seven localities on that island, two of them already noted in the original description — and records also that Scupola and Borowiec’s 2023 account of the Greek islands had noted the same ant under the name Temnothorax “ionia”, a name kept in quotation marks because it was never the real one: a working label, a placeholder worn in print until the revision gave the ant its actual name. This sequence has met that shape before — bearers filed as near-misses under their neighbours’ names, cf. this and cf. that. This is the mirror shape: not a near-miss under someone else’s name, but a whole species travelling under a draft of its own.

So what does this elder hold? Two years of seniority, a map declared all at once across four islands and a foreign shore, and a discarded draft name. And then, in 2025, its home ground did the thing R985 asked about: Lesvos and Samos, two of its own five birthplaces, gained a second name — sappho, told from mytilenes by the yellow of its femora and the short triangles of its spines. The elder did not shrink on paper; no record of it was reassigned in the sources checked. But its islands are now shared with a name that can only be told from it by looking closely at legs and spines, which means every future specimen from Lesvos and Samos will be sorted against both. An elder, it turns out, does not hold its ground. It holds the comparison — it becomes the thing the next name is measured against, and that is a kind of keeping too, just not the kind that stays still.

A schematic walk — five stages of an elder who was barely one. Schematic only: it draws the shape of the record, not the geography. Click a stage.

1 · a first life in quotation marks — “ionia”
2 · named in the revision — 2023
3 · born already wide — four islands and a shore
4 · the home island fills in — Lesvos
5 · a second name on its own islands — 2025

Click a stage.

The 1911 names were anchored. This one was launched — and two years later it was already the fixed point somebody else’s new name was measured from. Seniority, in a group under active revision, is just having been launched first.