Assembled by the knife

the onion's tear gas does not exist until you cut it

An onion sitting whole on the counter is harmless, and not by restraint. The chemical that makes you cry — syn-propanethial-S-oxide — is not in it. Not stored, not waiting. What the onion keeps instead is a kit: sulfur-rich precursor compounds in one part of the cell, enzymes in another, kept apart by walls. The gas is assembled only when the walls break, and the thing that breaks them is your knife.

Cut, and the assembly runs in two steps. First, an enzyme called alliinase converts the precursor isoalliin into 1-propenesulfenic acid. Then a second enzyme rearranges that acid into the volatile tear factor itself, which rises, reaches the cornea, and trips the nerves that order tears. The tears are a rinse cycle. The onion was never aiming at you in particular; it is a trap for anything that bites it, built at the moment of the bite.

The second step hid for a long time. For years the sulfenic acid was assumed to fall apart into the tear gas on its own, spontaneously. The clue that something was missing was garlic: garlic carries alliinase and similar precursors, yet chopping it leaves your eyes dry. Add alliinase to the precursor in a lab and no tear gas appears. There had to be another enzyme — one onions have and garlic lacks. In 2002 Imai and colleagues found it and named it plainly: lachrymatory factor synthase. Part of one of the most familiar sensations in any kitchen went undiscovered until this century, because the trail was an absence in a cousin.

Which raises the obvious experiment: remove the assembler. In 2008, researchers in New Zealand and Japan silenced the synthase gene with RNA interference and got onions that could be crushed without drawing tears. And the chemistry did not simply lose a step — it rerouted. The sulfur that would have left as tear gas stayed, and more of it ended up in thiosulfinates, the compounds behind much of an onion's flavour. Subtract the tears and you do not get a blander onion; you may get a stronger-tasting one, because the gas was made of flavour all along, spent into the air. In 2026 a Chiba University and House Foods team knocked the same gene out with CRISPR — a real proof of concept, though the edited plants grew poorly and none set seed. Nobody is selling that onion.

The tearless onion you can actually buy took the other road. Sunions are not gene-edited at all: they are the product of more than three decades of conventional breeding, sold in North America since 2017, and they go the unusual way in storage — most onions grow more pungent sitting in the dark; these grow milder and sweeter until they pass a no-cry test. Two routes to the same dry eye: take out the one enzyme that finishes the assembly, or breed the whole kit down until the assembly barely matters.

An intact onion is a weapon in pieces, and the pieces are harmless, and the weapon exists for perhaps a few seconds of chemistry at a time. It is stored nowhere. It happens.

Sources: syn-Propanethial-S-oxide · Discover, “Why Do Onions Make Us Cry?” · ScienceDaily on the 2008 tearless onion · Genetic Literacy Project on the 2026 CRISPR work · Seed World on Sunions