Arrived At Twice

Keeping at the far end, reached a second time — a workerless parasite of Greece with almost exactly the life of corsicus, on the same host, whose describers argued it did not inherit that life from corsicus at all

R963 closed by pointing to the closest relative of Myrmoxenus corsicus, and this page goes there — Temnothorax adlerzi (Douwes, Jessen & Buschinger, 1988), described as Epimyrma adlerzi and also carried as Myrmoxenus adlerzi. The puzzle is in the pairing itself. By life, adlerzi is corsicus again, item for item. By body, and by the later family tree, it belongs somewhere else entirely. If both readings hold, the far end of the slide was not reached once and shared; it was arrived at twice.

First, the life is almost identical, and its own describers said so. The 1988 description, based on material from southern, central and northern Greece, presents a workerless parasite on the same single host, Temnothorax exilis (then placed in Leptothorax), with a female-biased sex ratio and mating inside the nest. Its queen, after entering a host nest, kills the resident host queen by protracted throttling with her mandibles — the genus act, kept here as in corsicus. Later work pairs the two in the same frame: workerless murder-parasites, producing only one or a few broods of sexuals on a workforce inherited at the takeover and spent as those host workers die. Nothing in that life needs corsicus to explain it, and that is the point its describers pressed.

Second, the body points at a different relative. Morphologically, the description found adlerzi very similar not to corsicus but to ravouxi — a slave-making species that still has workers of its own and renews its stock by raids. The 2024 revision of the group keeps that difficulty: outward features separate adlerzi gynes from every species in the revision except ravouxi, and telling those two apart reliably takes a combination of five measurements, with a classification success of about 94.5 percent on the gynes measured (seventeen for adlerzi in its table). So the animal that lives like corsicus measures like a raider. Resemblance in the life and resemblance in the body pull in opposite directions, and only one of them can be the inheritance.

Third, workerless here means almost, but not quite, absolute. The revision states it carefully: only gynes have been found in nature, though a single worker is reported to have developed under laboratory conditions. The phylogenetic study gives the laboratory record a denominator, from the work it cites: one worker among 745 female offspring of adlerzi. Its authors read that rarity as retained, cryptic plasticity — the capacity to make a worker not wholly erased, only almost never expressed — rather than a fixed genetic loss of the caste. In nature, on the accounts read, the colony still runs exactly as corsicus does: sexuals only, reared by exilis workers who cannot be replaced once their queen is dead.

Fourth, the family tree sides with the describers. The 1988 authors, despite the biological near-identity with corsicus, suggested an independent evolution of workerlessness in the two species. The 2015 phylogenetic study of the genus, built from mitochondrial and nuclear sequences, reached a matching shape: the workerless forms do not form a single cluster, the worker caste was lost convergently at least three times across the genus, and adlerzi in particular sits within the ravouxi line — the very slave-maker its body resembles. The same study notes that rapid brood, sexuals raised from brood that does not overwinter, arose separately in kraussei, in corsicus and in adlerzi, and reads that speed as fitted to a raidless life bounded by the workers present at the usurpation. Its authors are candid about the limits: the branching is shallow and some placements are inconsistent, so the reconstruction is tentative. Tentative is not nothing, though — two independent lines, the describers’ judgement and the later tree, point the same way. The karyotype, for what it is worth, does not separate them: adlerzi shares the count reported for its congeners.

Last, notice what kind of keeping a repeated far end is. Corsicus kept by inheritance alone: mate at home, throttle the host queen, spend the inherited workers on one fast round of sexuals. Adlerzi keeps in exactly that way — same host, same throttling, same female-biased, in-nest mating, same deadline — and apparently built that whole economy separately, out of a raiding ancestor much closer to hand. The slide from slave-making to workerlessness, which the last several pages read as one road with a middle and an end, turns out to be a slope that more than one lineage has gone down on its own. Greece holds the second arrival: known, in the revision’s wording, only from parts of northern and southern Greece, on exilis alone in all twelve samples it investigated.

A walk through a keeping arrived at twice. Five stages: a gyne-only parasite described from Greece; a queen entering an exilis nest and throttling its queen; mating inside the nest with a female-biased ratio; sexuals raised fast by inherited workers, one worker in 745 in the laboratory record; and a far end reached separately, inside the ravouxi line. Schematic, compressed from the published accounts, with the judgements labelled as judgements.

Walk it in order.

Schematic only: the stages compress a species description, a genus phylogeny, a review framing and a taxonomic revision, so no single colony is promised this exact story. Labelled cautions: do not say adlerzi has never produced a worker — none has been found in nature, but a single worker is reported from laboratory conditions, counted in the phylogeny’s cited work as one in 745 female offspring. Do not give it a second host past Temnothorax exilis, or a range past Greece: the revision says parts of northern and southern Greece, while the original description’s material came from southern, central and northern Greece — two wordings, kept apart on this page, not merged into one range. Do not assign it the several-days throttling timed for corsicus — its own account says protracted throttling, with no separate figure carried over. Do not call corsicus its closest relative in the tree’s sense: a corsicus account uses that phrase for the similarity of life, but adlerzi’s body is closest to ravouxi and the phylogeny places it within the ravouxi line. And do not present independent evolution as proven beyond the sources’ own hedges — the describers suggested it, the phylogeny supports a convergent loss at least three times in the genus, and that study calls its own reconstruction tentative on a shallow tree.