Almost certain

A synonym of Crematogaster schmidti kept down by the strongest measurement any kept synonym in the file received — an Edirne type worker, measured from its photographs at 0.984, whose paragraph in the 2026 revision needs no second witness at all

R1006 followed the type no one could reach, confirmed on a text alone, and ended on its mirror. This page follows that mirror alone. Everything below is summarised in my own words, with no quoted text beyond bare collecting and bibliographic data.

First, what the name is. Crematogaster scutellaris medispina was published by Forel in 1905 as a variety under scutellaris — a different parent from karawaewi, published the same year under auberti. In 1922 Emery made it a junior synonym of Crematogaster schmidti, and there it has stayed. In the 2026 revision its synonymy line carries the strongest basis phrase the schmidti synonyms are given, in paraphrase: confirmed by morphometric analyses. Its mirror's line, in the same list, in the same typeface, carries the weakest: confirmed on zoogeography and the original description. The list prints them as equals. The sentences underneath do not.

Second, what the specimen is. The account describes a single type worker — Table 2 lists it as the medispina syntype — whose labels, paraphrased here, name it as Forel's variety medispina of Crematogaster scutellaris, marked as a type, from Adrianopel, the old name for Edirne, collected by Flach, and held in Forel's collection. It is housed in Geneva, at the MHNG, and its pictures on AntWeb carry the identifier CASENT0908488. Edirne is not a reported point outside the revision's map, the way Crimea was for karawaewi: it stands inside the account's own list of eleven sampled schmidti localities, at 41.68° N, 26.56° E, credited there to D. Flach — the last and easternmost of the eleven, in Turkish Thrace.

Third, how it was judged. Like the Patras worker and the Dalmatian stand-in, this worker was not measured on a stage in this revision; it was measured digitally from its AntWeb photographs and run as a wild card against the four clusters formed from 201 workers in 68 nests. It came back at 0.984 to schmidti. The rivals, from Table 2, are 0.002 to the Cretan ariadnae, 0.013 to the mainland graeca and 0.001 to ionia — together, 0.016 left standing for every other reading combined. Of the six type workers in the table, only one scored higher: the Patras ionia syntype at 0.990. That score expelled its bearer from its own type series. This score, six thousandths lower, does the opposite work: it holds a dead name down in its synonymy, and holds it down harder than the synonymy needed. Near-certainty, it turns out, is directionless — what it does depends entirely on which cluster it points at.

Fourth, listen to what is not said. Read the schmidti type paragraphs side by side and each of the others needs a supporting sentence. The christowitchii syntypes, at 0.620 and 0.898, are affirmed by a Bulgarian origin plus a colour sentence from 1892. The damaged schmidti type, with no number at all, is matched strongly by colour and place. Karawaewi, with no body at all, fits best on place plus a 1905 description. The medispina paragraph has no such sentence. Label, housing, identifier, score — and it stops. The number is allowed to stand alone because, alone, it is enough. That silence is the paragraph's own strength-word, and it is louder than affirms.

So do the two 1905 confirmations land with the same weight? In the synonymy list, yes: medispina and karawaewi sit three lines apart, each recorded as a junior synonym, each marked confirmed, typographically indistinguishable. In the evidence underneath, they are the two ends of the ladder this whole sequence has been climbing down: 0.984 measured from a photographed body in a named drawer, against no body, no drawer, no picture and a comparative verb. The strongest-kept synonym holds something the text-kept one cannot — not a different verdict, but a verdict that does not need to promise a future check. Its confirmation is finished. Karawaewi's is a deferral honestly labelled; medispina's needs no label, because there is nothing left to defer. That is also what the surplus is for: without a top rung at 0.984, the bottom rung's fits best would look like the normal price of a confirmation. The excess certainty of the kept synonym is what makes the other one's thinness visible at all.

The walk — five moments in one dead name's working life, schematic only. Click each stage.

described from Edirne, 1905
sunk under schmidti, 1922
photographed in Geneva
measured from pictures, at 0.984
confirmed by measurement, 2026

Pick a stage.

The unreachable name is held by a promise to check its body later. This name is held by a body that has already been checked, from its photographs, almost to certainty — and the six thousandths between it and expulsion are a reminder that the same instrument, at the same strength, keeps one name down and throws another one out.